GROTUS' ACORN

God girl grill gridiron
Showing posts with label medicine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label medicine. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Give the people what they want, Grotus' Acorn

sounds fair

Seeing as I gave McCain's plan a shakedown, it's only fair - as was pointed out here at the Acorn - to similarly examine Obama's. So I'll do that on Friday. It's a bit more complicated, though, and there's a lot more material to sift through. Unlike McCain, Obama's plan is available in the easily-digestible soundbite form, and as a much-more detailed .pdf. And I feel compelled to read and digest the latter if I am to adequately comment on it.

At a first glance, Obama's plan does represent a step towards nationalized healthcare. But more on that later.

Also, I should be fair to McCain's plan and clarify: earlier I said that he would recoup the costs of his healthcare plan by making employer-sponsored healthcare benefits taxable. On initial glance, it looks terrible, as employer-sponsored healthcare will evaporate if everything goes off according to McCain's plan. In actuality, he would offset the costs of a $5,000 tax credit by reforming Medicare and encouraging preventative care.

This is one area where the two candidates are in agreement. No matter who is elected, the next President will push for doctors to be paid for diagnosis, preventative care, and care coordination. It amounts to an investment: medical care will be more costly on the whole for a number of years, but will be less expensive in the long run. Moreover, both candidates want doctors not to be paid for gross medical errors. In my opinion, these reforms would redistribute responsibility (risk and pay) over an entire medical team. It's a sound strategy that reflects the current trend in medicine towards team-based coordinated care and greater emphasis on the ounce of prevention.


Auburn Tigers, I haven't forgotten you

I'm just bracing myself for the mountain brawl that comes tomorrow night. When this game was originally announced, I was excited - a chance to whip White and Co. and vault into national title consideration. And now... I'd be happy to escape Morgantown with our team completely free of mountain moonshine whupass.

I'm not convinced that our team is good enough in any aspect to pull this one out. In our four most recent games, the defense has given up an average of 19 points via 303 total yards (153 through the air and 150 on the ground.) If we were to take our team over those four games and give it independent rankings, it would be #35 in points per game, #21 in total yards, and #41 in rushing defense*.

Granted, there are a number of potential reasons why. The injuries and the three-and-outs don't help anything. But the latter isn't going away - especially in Morgantown at night - unless we have some sort of Ensmingerian renaissance. I don't really see that happening. So the defense has to run the marathon again. If we couldn't do it against Arkansas, can we hope to do it against West Virginia?



*...and also #6 in passing defense. While our young secondary has performed admirably well, I think this number reflects the ability of teams to run on our defense.

Friday, October 17, 2008

McCain's market-based health insurance plan

McCain's plan to solve the problem of rising health care costs and the growing ranks of the uninsured:
  • Allow people to buy health insurance across state lines, opening competition for health insurance plans nationwide on an individual basis
  • Give a tax credit ($2500 to individuals, $5000 to families) that will provide the money to purchase a basic plan
  • Recoup these costs by making employer-sponsored healthcare benefits taxable
On the surface, the raw economics seem to be in McCain's favor. Competition lowers the price for the consumer, and in this respect it makes sense to allow the end consumer - the patient, you and me - to buy from whom we choose, knowing the entire cost of our healthcare. And perhaps this means that employee-sponsored health care plans will bite the dust, but in the name of the market they should, shouldn't they?

The problem is that insurance is inherently a form of socialism, and the bulk of healthy consumers punch below their weight when it comes to healthcare costs. The sickest 1% of our citizens account for 27% of our healthcare costs, the sickest 5% account for 38%, and so on - you see where this is going. It's a stable statistic. This is why we have insurance - the bulk of healthy people willingly transfer their wealth to the currently sick people, in exchange for the good of being prepared for the possibility of becoming sick. Scratch and scratch. Insurance agencies stay one step ahead in this game by signing up a whole bunch of healthy people. Their model is simple: revenue is provided by healthy insurees who pay in more than they take out, while overhead and unhealthy insurees constitute the expenditures. It's exactly the same idea that Cap One is taking to the bank: identify and sign the least costly consumers, and they will more than compensate for the more risky consumers. The more healthy buyers the bigger their margin.

The complication insurers want to avoid is called adverse selection: it can be summed up as "the only people who buy insurance are those who benefit from it." In the case of health insurance, this would mean that the only people who buy insurance are the sick. You can see how this instantly turns the entire balance sheet red. Adverse selection occurs when the insured (or the lessee) holds some power over their insurer (or lessor.) For health insurance, this typically results from an asymetry of information, IE, the potential insured withholds information about health issues that make him more risky, such as pre-existing conditions or cigarette smoking. So, insurance companies control that risk-benefit ratio with medical underwriting (the infamous pre-coverage health exam by which so many people are given higher rates or denied coverage) and then adjusting premiums for risk.

If McCain's plan is enacted and works as designed, the bulk of consumers will buy cheaper insurance than they already have. The design of the plan is to incentivize Americans to ditch their expensive employer-sponsored plan for the cheaper, primary care-intensive ounce of prevention. In fact, they might be forced to - the average cost of insurance for an American family is around $12,000, of which $8,000 is usually paid by imployer. $9,000 (the sum of what families already pay plus their tax credit) will get you a pretty decent plan that would be adequate for most healthy families, and with greater care coordination and preventative care, this will probably be okay for healthy Americans. However, in doing so they will have self-formed a gigantic low-cost risk pool. Credit card companies are known for risk pooling: they form groups of lessees with similar credit ratings and buy and sell them as aggregates. This allows the company to manage these accounts much as one might manage a portfolio of stocks. But imagine if, say, CapOne was forced to sell off all its financially-savvy lessees and accept only the most high-risk. They'd go bankrupt because their margin would go to nil. This is exactly the situation that will occur if every healthy American is allowed to go buy the cheapest adequate individual plan out there - they will self-pool in cheaper plans and no longer will contribute to the pool providing for the sickest citizens.

In other words, if the McCain plan works as designed, it will induce adverse selection. Because an insurance company's margin is the direct product of the ratio of healthy and sick insurees, they would have to adjust for this market realignment or face bankruptcy.

Only now, the insurance company can not do anything about adverse selection, because adverse selection is built into the system. McCain's health plan is designed to prevent insurance companies from artificially adjusting their risk pool (as a credit card company might) so they have to compete in a price market for insurees, IE, they have to drop their price. This would be financially untenable. A company providing for the care of a large pool of high-risk individuals would have to lower their premiums to competitive market prices just to retain the low-risk individuals that form their revenue base. But the cost to the company for the high-risk individuals remains high: their cost to the company is directly determined by their cost of care, a number determined not by market forces, but by the medical infrastructure. In a market where low-risk individuals are able to drive down the price of insurance by self-pooling, the high-cost individuals essentially represent a dramatically increased overhead that is robust to market forces. The result is that, at lower prices, this company would need to expand their low-risk pool to maintain the margin at a lower premium-per-person. But in order to expand their low-risk pool, they must become more competitive in the market, IE, lower prices. This would require more customers, requiring lower prices, etc. ad nauseum. The process is analagous to inflation. Smaller non-catastrophic insurance providers that do not insure large numbers of high-risk patients (such as United Concordia) would be able to bleed the big guys of their revenue base.

What happens then? The sick stick with what they've got because they have no incentive to change insurances - no company can offer them a premium significantly lower than the cost determined by the medical infrastructure. As their insurance company's margin decreases, their premium must increase if the company is to continue to provide for care and turn a profit. One might think that in an environment of increasing premiums, whoever raises premiums slowest "wins." But while insurance companies have an incentive to compete for low-risk individuals, they have no incentive to compete for high-risk individuals. This is because these people represent pure expenditure, and it is financially foolish to lower prices in order to increase expenditure. Without an employer to sponsor multiple employees as a bloc and thus force insurance companies to accept high-risk individuals as part of the pool, insurance companies should and would treat them as individuals. There may be an incentive to raise premiums only to the a level acceptable by the market, but as revenue-per-insuree decreases, there is certainly an incentive to minimize the expenditures due to high-risk individuals by raising their premiums.

You can see that the overall effect is everyone's insurance premiums will approach the actual direct cost of their healthcare (some asymptote designated by the cost of medical infrastructure.) For many Americans, this would be just fine because they don't get sick too often or too badly, and they'll catch a break. But for a significant portion of America, though, this would be devastating. It's $100 just to get your blood gases checked. What happens when you need a 5-day stay in the ICU? What happens when your croupy kid needs to be intubated? When someone needs IV tPA for a stroke? The costs are astronomical. Just apply the relevant facts: ~30% of the population receives ~90% of the total US healthcare expenditures, which came to $2.26 trillion in 2007. That's $22,198 per person, per year for 3 of 10 Americans. They would forfeit half an average year's pay. The cost of healthcare would be shifted from the population as a whole (as insurance is designed to work) to those who need it the most. McCain's"market of insurances" plan defeats the purpose of having health insurance at all.

This conclusion should have been obvious, right from the start. The demand for healthcare among those who really need it is inherently high and the supply (by virtue of the necessary expertise, infrastructure, research and safety precautions) is inherently low. In a situation of fixed supply and high demand, the most basic tenets of economics dictate that price will always be high. This is one example of why pure market economics can not solve the problems with health care. Price increases in direct proportion to your need, and people's very lives depend on healthcare. You can not afford to buy your life.

But what's really sticky is that very few people end up in the same risk pool they started in. The low-risk pool is composed primarily of the young and healthy, whereas the high-risk pool is mostly made up of the old and ill. As people age, their chance of being severely hurt or contracting some devastating disease goes up. Under a purely free-market system such as McCain's, their direct cost of healthcare (their insurance premium) will similarly increase as insurance companies risk-adjust their premiums in accordance with the demands of the market and the raw cost of our healthcare infrastructure. The end result is that when the truly expensive emergency or late-life care is needed, health insurance will not soften the blow. This plan takes all the non-insured and the adequately insured and incentivizes them to become under-insured.

The real problem with health care is not that insurance is expensive, insurance is expensive because there are problems with healthcare. We Americans face the old trilemma: effective, available, cheap - pick two. Infrastructure overhaul and cultural change would be a good start on this mammoth problem but probably wouldn't solve it entirely. It isn't encouraging that John McCain "Will Develop A Strategy For Meeting The Challenge Of A Population Needing Greater Long-Term Care For Make Benefit Glorious Nation of America," but I can't hold that against him. So he hasn't come up with a strategy for solving that problem, join the club John McCain, we call it America. But simply decreasing the cost of insurance isn't going to solve the underlying problems. It's like the gas prices I argued with my Dad about. He saw gas prices lose a buck, and said "Oh good, the market's working." In a sense, I agree that sure, when people are less willing to pay for gas, the price goes down to reflect the decrease in demand. It's good that we can adjust like that. But the current drop in gas prices merely reflects the fact that our economy is a wreck. It is not encouraging to see a 25% drop in gas prices in the span of a week - in fact, it's kind of ominous to see rats jumping ship. It's the same situation with health insurance: just because the cost of insurance goes down for the average American does not mean any real problem has been solved. It just reflects the fact that when people can't get much they settle for little, and those who can't settle pay out the nose. It's important to remember that we all run the risk of becoming the high-risk patient - all it takes is one drunk driver, one bad infection, one weird genetic condition and you could be totaled. Like the kids I took care of in the ICU last month.

I'm not saying that to be sentimental. I just want to point out that while the market would shelter healthy people like you and me, it would ravage those who absolutely require its services because that's the way a market works. Supply and demand. And that's fine for a lot of things. A great deal of problems are best solved by the market's coldly brutal efficiency. But not healthcare, and certainly not like this.

Friday, September 12, 2008

It's so much better down here....

As luck would have it, my fiancee matched at Wake Forest for her residency. And I mean, pure luck as in someone suggested it to her and she thought, sure, why not? And boom! It ended up being her favorite place. And apparently they liked her, too. So naturally, it's imperative that I also match at Wake, as the nearest program is an hour away in Charlotte or an hour away in Durham. Crap. Commuting from Burlington every day = no. So as medical students are wont to do, I decided to do a clerkship at my desired residency, so to get my foot in the door and make with the face-time. You know, a sort of audition-before-the-audition. Like spring camps. I'm walking-on and hoping for a scholarship.

To be perfectly honest, I didn't know much about the pediatrics department before I got here. I knew, sure, it's a great hospital, and hey, they sure treat my girl well. And being that it's Wake Forest, I felt pretty certain that my level of pediatric training would be stellar. But I didn't really know what to expect upon arriving. But imagine my happiness - and this should come as no surprise to many of you - to find out that the South is, quite simply, better than the northern locales I've haunted the last few years.

When I was about shoulder-high, we lived in a small rural community outside Atlanta. Those three years were the golden years of my childhood. My neighbor's lawn was a gridiron every fall day, football in the biting-tackle five-mississippi rush two-completions-a-first and one-blitz-or-sneak-every-four style, watch for fire ants and don't land in Josh's Mom's azaleas. Every self-respecting male would line up for a long afternoon of man coverage and touchdowns in the driveway. We knew each other's college teams and no one gave a crap about the falcons and it was glorious. What I wouldn't give to be eight years old again, sweating stripes in my tee shirt and dragging two unlucky kids down to the concrete for seven.

But halfway through fifth grade, we moved to Richmond, where I would spend most of my childhood. Everything was different. Most poignantly, the other neighborhood whelps had little-to-no interest in the glory of a day ended in a cloud of dust. When we did play, it was three of us playing touch ball in the street and one guy QB'ing both ways. It ended up being a matter of attitude... a sort of Northern attitude.

See, Richmond's got Southern credentials. How can it not? It was the capital of the Confederacy. We've even got a statue of ol' Jefferson Davis on our Monument Avenue.* But the shadow of Maryland is cast long, like a deep blue cloak over the heart of Virginia. And like the Northerners I've come to know - and even enjoy - Richmonders are a closed lot. It takes 365 days of constant residence in Richmond to be accepted into society to the point that you are safe to address cautiously in public. This is no exaggeration or hyperbolic detail - my mother endured a full year to the day of grocery-store isolation before the Richmond switch was flipped and someone said hi to her. Heaven forbid you speak to a stranger in the elevator, and if you must enunciate the number of your floor, be courteous but curt. The Northerners just aren't friendly like the Southerners are.

Contrast this to the South where (God bless it) you go down to the Piggly-Wiggly and leave with three new best friends. My fiancee was not prepared for such openness and it honestly freaked her out. She and her mother left the Harris Teeter frankly astonished at a women who divulged her entire life story and the history of her progeny right there in the aisles. Here in - dare I say it - the pleasanter part of America, this is common practice.

Honestly I don't blame Richmond. Being that the confederates located their capital practically on Lincoln's beard, they were and remain the front line of a war that smolders on in the culture. Fairfax - spittin' distance from Maryland - long ago succumbed to the ravages of creeping Northernism and are flat-out Yankee in speech and decorum. Richmond, really, isn't too far down the road (commutable by morning train, believe it or not.) It's sad but only expectable that Richmond would become the Southern capital whose mannerisms divest her citizens of their twangs and drawls until they sound... shudder... like Marylanders.**

But North Carolina is safe, protected by Tennessee to the west and the broad band of unpopulated Piedmont north of Lake Gaston that my mother terms "the South Hill dead zone." Seventy miles of deeply forested and seldom-exited highway buffer the inevitable bleed-through of Yankee blueblood from Carolina's rolling hills. And it is just so much better down here.

Why? Lots of reasons. Part the first:


no one takes my cup

Life as a medical student is frequently boring. There are long periods on rounds in which an attending is fitfully adjusting some line, or pimping another student, or explaining something which you've already looked up, or just sitting around on the phone or writing orders or - you get the picture. But professionalism dictates that we refrain from doodling, whistling, or otherwise occupying ourselves - we are a team, and we are working together. Two things will help you out of this predicament. The first is, crackers. I've developed a sophisticated palate that delights in the subtle flavor and textural detail of saltines and graham crackers, inevitably free and mercifully crunchy. But what's even better is the cup of ice. Ever ready to quench your thirst or occupy your mind with crisp ice, it is your silent and faithful companion. And as my friends know, I'm usually thirsty. Every unit has an ice machine and an unquenchable stack of styrofoam cups. So I always have my cup of ice.

But you can't just take it anywhere - it would be rude to sip and sup while you're, say, listening to your patient's breath sounds. That just isn't done. So, the cup must be relinquished to enter the room. And that's when the nurses strike. Now, I try to do my part. The cup is clearly labeled with my name in attractive and legible print. But for some reason unknown to me, the northern unit nurses don't abide a cup bein' left about, whether some medical student's got his name written right there on it or not. The moment your cup is unattended, it's free game and that means it grows legs. Right into the trash.

Here in the hospitable South, no one takes my cup. I have left a cup for hours all on its lonesome, and returned to see it happily awaiting fresh ice and refreshment to the brim.


biscuits

Just as the nurses are swift and silent in their banishment of empty cups, the cafeterias in the North are insidious in their erosion of the highest ideals of breakfast cuisine. For a while, I didn't even realize what was amiss, though I always sensed that something was dreadfully, horribly wrong. And then it dawned on me: I say to you there are no biscuits.

Southerners, I know you, you're laughing. No biscuits, you fool? you may be thinking. Did you look oh I don't know in the cafeteria? It didn't register with me, either. Sure, I don't choose biscuits every single time I eat before 11:00. I'm not above the occasional croissant. I'll eat butter just on my grits. But for pity's sake, biscuits at least have to be an option. For three years, I bought my breakfast, blithely accepting the croissant, the English muffin, the bagel every day with no thought to what had been eradicated from my morning as I knew it.

I don't ask for much. I just want a servicable biscuit with my breakfast. It don't gotta be Bojangles, but we all know what a biscuit is; well, all we sensible folks. Don't even get me started on the pale-brown lumps of hardtack that the Yankees expect me to glom down slathered in salt-salt-and-burnt-bits gravy of identical, pasty complexion. It had been so long without edible biscuits that I was pleasantly surprised to find them at the caf here at Wake Forest. And damn, that's a good biscuit. Got that buttery, crispy lid that leaves a dust of salt onto your fingertips, and a soft flaky interior that puffs a little steam as you bite down. And it does that biscuit thing... I can't explain how a biscuit can be delectably moist and tender, and yet cleave to the top of your mouth like peanut butter. But you know what I mean. Them's a real biscuit, and what pleasure after so long. I was only able to contain myself because my fiancee and I ate Bojangles at the Charlotte airport on the most recent trip up to Pittsburgh - I had at least tasted a biscuit within the last week.

Now imagine my satisfaction upon realizing that these same biscuits are served every day with fried chicken. I'll be! It's good to be home, folks. Home where they make 'em some biscuits.


Also, grits - funny story in and of itself to be blogged out later. I'm looking at you, Dad.


* I don't know if you follow Richmond news. Ok, actually, I know that you don't. Monument Avenue is named for the monuments to Southern generals placed along its oak-lined streets at major intersections. There was a big stink in the mid 1990's when the city decided to add to the pantheon for the first time in 67 years and who do you think they chose? Humanitarian, athlete, and Richmonder: Arthur Ashe. Regardless of the arguments pro and con (both of which had their merits) for a black 20th century tennis player chillin' with J.E.B. and Stonewall, the statue's placement ended hilariously: Who's got the books now, children? MWAHAHAHA!

** Depressingly true. If I had a nickel for every time I've been told I have no Southern accent... well, I'd be ashamed to tell you how rich I'd be. And I won't reveal here how shamefully I embarassed myself in front of my father one awful fall day. T'weren't pretty, friends.

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

Call-Bloggin' Again

Spare moment on call again, because of my own peculiar meteorology.

See, medicine has strange weather-based terms to describe a doctor's tendency to attract or not attract patients. Some people are black clouds. Black clouds are inundated with new admissions, nursing pages, and patients' problems the moment they step on the hospital grounds, and usually have to fling their pagers away at the end of the shift, lest they be roped into staying half a day more. White clouds, in contrast, get a ton of sleep and are bored as hell because their patients are the healthiest people God ever set on the earth.

I'm a different sort of guy. I get no more and no less patients than a normal person... they're just never where they're rumored to be. If I'm told that my patient is in the post-op care unit, that means they've actually gone up to the floor. If someone says they're on their way to the hospital, then quite the opposite is likely to be true. Seems like I spend the greater part of the day hunting down my patients in improbable locales. Once, we were taking a kid from the OR back to the NICU, and I volunteered - eager-beaverly - to go ahead and secure an elevator. In the thirty seconds it took for me to get to the elevator and exercise clinical responsibility (read: kick people out of the elevator) my patient desaturated and went back to the OR. Naturally it felt totally awesome to kick some family out of the elevator and then stand there for five minutes waiting for a gurney that would never arrive, enduring their confused stares. Even on very small floors, my patients move about willy-nilly. I'm not a black cloud, or a white cloud, I'm.. what? A patch of fog?

My patient earlier tonight left from one hospital that's about 6 minutes away, and took two hours to materialize. God alone knows where he was.

Anyway, here on my pediatrics AI it's been pretty enjoyable when it isn't musical chairs. Highlights include:

1. The heavy metal kid. Met him one afternoon as I did his admission. He's sittin' there in bed kind of glum - but he's got a Metallica belt buckle and an Ozzy Osbourne shirt on. And not just any Metallica belt buckle, but one in the shape of the "ninja star" on the Load and Reload albums. So I ask him if he liked St. Anger. "No, it sucked." And what bands does he listen to? "Just hardcore stuff, probably you haven't heard of them." I say try me, and he rattles off a couple band names including the awesome Job for Cowboy. When I mention seeing Between the Buried and Me recently in Lemoyne, he perks up immediately and asks me if I knew about this show coming up soon at a local joint. Surprise, surprise: baby-faced soft-spoken young doctors listen to heavy metal, too. Ran into him again today as he and his mom were dropping off some baked goods for the nurses. Turns out he went to that show (at which every band was "insane") and is going to several dozen more in the next few months. Knock 'em dead, kid.

2. The cutest girl on the face of the planet. Save your polaroids of doe-eyed neices, your first-steps DVD's, and your mouths-of-the-babes anecdotes, I've totally got them beat. I walk into this girl's room just to check up on her and she has the bed cranked up about four feet off the floor. The child life therapist is in there with her, and as I come up to say hi, my patient says "You can't get to me because I'm a princess. We're both princesses." Her majesty then informs me that I must pay her one thousand dollars, also due to her status as young royalty. Being quite magnanimous for such a young age, my patient the princess delivers the same proclamation to anyone else who enters the room, being another medical student and two nurses. She looks up from her adorable-girl video game and counts aloud with satisfaction, "One, two, three, four thousand dollars. That's enough for one hundred ponies."

3. Nerf wars. There was this little guy (gone home now) who got into the nurses' stash of Nerf weapons and would sneak around the floor assassinating whomsoever he pleased. Nurses, attendings, other patients and yes, even yours truly fell to his guerrilla tactics. I was shot repeatedly in the leg with a pump-action ball-launcher one day while filling out a discharge sheet, and he even gave a quick lesson in the root cause of his tactical dominance. "You never see me," he said with some glee, "because I always come from this side." Later I found a Nerf pistol and launched a sneak attack of my own, provoking a ferocious firefight in the hall. But that was nothing compared to when he repeatedly took down one of the nurses, a hard-bitten girl who dug up a battery-operated Nerf-dart gatling gun and straight up emptied the magazine on him.

4. MRSA-Ball. There's an entity known as MRSA* which stands for methicillin-resistant Staph aureus. By now, you've heard something about it but the bottom line is it's a particularly mean kind of staph that's also a good bit harder to kill. For most people, MRSA doesn't present a daily health risk because they can fight it off or take some Bactrim, but it can do a number on certain hospital patients. So to prevent the spread of MRSA through the hospital, every patient is swabbed to see if they have it and if they do, they're placed on contact isolation. Which means that nurses, doctors, and med students have to wear a gown and gloves when examining the patient. Whether that's effective is somewhat debatable.

But what certainly isn't effective in preventing the spread of MRSA is confining your MRSA-colonized seven year old patient to her room but giving her a giant ball with which to play catch with the nurses and anyone else who she can sucker. Namely, me. I gamely played MRSA-ball with her for a while, but it quickly got out of hand when she decided it would be fun to try and make me miss. Which means, throw the ball down the hallway to her left and right. She tagged my resident in the back of the head, nearly knocked over a cart, and sent nurses scattering before her staph-coated virulent projectile. After a while it was lunch time so I had to get going. I turn to my attending and say "I'm just going to wash my hands." And she says, "YEAH."


*pronounced "mersa," "emm arr ess eh," "Dear-God-don't-touch-anything" or "everybody's-got-it-in-their-nasal-mucosa-already" depending on whom you talk to.

Saturday, May 3, 2008

All those merit badges for nothing...



When I was in sixth or seventh grade, I went to Boy Scout camp at Powhatan Scout Reservation. Boy that was fun - mountain lakes, A-6 intruders, copperheads and best of all: woodcarving. It was my very first scout camp and they were already going to let us use knives. Awesome!

It's been said that a sharp knife is a safe knife, because you're less likely to be using a lot of pressure to make a cut, and therefore you won't slip and cut yourself. This is what the merit badge counselor told me as he honed my standard-issue red BSA pocketknife to a razor-like edge completely inappropriate for its construction, use, or owner. I demonstrated this shortly afterwards when, just prior to dinner, I was cutting toward my hand to make a stop-cut, sliced right into my left middle finger, and wound up needing six stitches. I even passed out in the camp clinic. My mom got a lovely phone call in the middle of the night that began "Pulaski County Hospital, can you hold? *click*"

That was when I learned that the safest knife is not necessarily a sharp knife, but one not wielded by an idiot. Rule number one is: cut away, away, away from yourself. Lest the dull tool in the box get cut by the nice sharp knife.


So naturally, having completed seven or eight years of scouting, an Eagle scout award, numerous trips for the OA, two treks, and a surgery clerkship, I've only gotten dumber. Four stitches dumber:

The limes ain't worth it, man!


I was cutting a lime into slices for some drinks for my girlfriend and me (we were having a nice, relaxing evening.) I managed to demonstrate exactly NOT what to do, which is:
  1. hold the lime in your hand
  2. place a gigantic turkey-carving fillet knife against the lime where you wish to make the cut
  3. think you're really cool
  4. apply downward pressure with your thumb and upward pressure with the machete you've chosen to mutilate produce with
  5. half cut your damn thumb off
  6. better get sewn up, you chump.
So my finger immediately starts spurting blood. I apply pressure with a rag, and sit down on the floor, because every time I cut myself like this, I pass out and have this bizarre seizure/dissociative fugue. My girlfriend (wonderful that she is) sat down in front of me, prepared to catch me should I pass out. She says the last thing I said was "I hate when I cut myself, I feel so weird." And then boom! I'm in the most vivid, realistic, forget-you-exist dream in fast-forward and boom! I'm back out of it again. It was the weirdest sensation. Imagine you've forgotten who you are, where you are, who your girlfriend is, what it feels like to have clothes on... thankfully I kept them on, but just think for a second: if you had never worn clothes before in your entire life, what would that feel like? Exactly - just like that. Freakin' bizarre. Meanwhile, I'm shaking, posturing, and trying desperately to remember who I am, where I am, and who this nice girl is who seems so very concerned. Bi-zarre.

My girl was pretty freaked out, to say the least. She said that I quickly did what I foretold, crumpling up in a little ball and making weird noises that she didn't know could even come out of my mouth. I was actually glad she was there to witness it, as when this (rarely) occurs, I usually just wake up extremely confused, not knowing what happened. She quickly got up, instructed me several times to lay on the floor, and went out to buy gauze. When she returned, she took a look at my finger and said, yes, we'll need to go to the ER.

Now, I dreaded that decision the very moment I overshot that damn lime. No one likes going and sitting in the waiting room - most of the time, if you aren't cardiac you're gonna wait. So we gathered up stuff to read and study for the anticipated hours of sitting, poured a bunch of water on my perfectly ashed-over charcoal, and walked over to the ER. But lo and behold, the hospital here has gotten a brand-new triage system. I was literally in a room within ten minutes. We were astonished. My girlfriend went to go get us some dinner, and she just saw me as I was getting roomed. In fact, we didn't even have time to eat before the PA was in there pumping me up with lidocaine and stitching me closed. It was really amazing how well we were served in that first half-hour.

The hour and a half afterwards, however, sucked. They completely forgot to discharge me. Being good medical students who dutifully appreciate the system (and who have been relentlessly hammered about attempting to work outside its margins) we waited. In fact, we waited until an entire hour had passed, before I got up and took a couple laps around the ER in search of my PA or the ER doc who'd come by at first to appraise my lime-finger. I didn't find them, but shortly after I returned to my girlfriend in the room, the doc comes by again and says "What are you still doing here?" "I'm waiting for my discharge instructions," I blithely replied. It was pretty stupid, all in all. They forgot that I hadn't left, and I really didn't need them to remember. But in the name of bureaucracy, I stayed. Shows you what you learn here in the ivory tower, eh?

What really bugged us wasn't staying, and wasn't being forgotten (we had a nice chat with an elderly patient who was in the room with us, she was great.) It was missing The Office, which, turns out was a beautiful, classic character-driven and situationally clever Office episode. Thankfully all the episodes are available online free-of-charge. Else I really, really would have felt stupid.

Live and learn, and learn again, and learn again a decade later.

Thursday, March 20, 2008

MATCH

So with a lot of finagling and back-bending and base-covering, I managed to get off work today to be with my girlfriend for the Match.

The Match is kind of an arcane process by which senior medical students get paired up with the programs that they like and that like them. Here's how it works: med students apply to residencies. If the residencies like them, then the med student gets an interview. The med student goes to the interview and evaluates the residency, just as the residency evaluates the med student. After everyone's done with their interviews, all the med students make their rank lists, whereby they list out all the programs they'd consider going to in the order of their preference. And likewise with the residencies - they rank the med students they'd like to have as residents. Everyone sends in their rank lists to the NRMP, who plugs everything into some computer program that figures out how to match everything, so that the students get their highest ranked choice possible and the residencies get their highest ranked students possible.

This all gets done sometime in February. The NRMP then waits about a month before they tell the medical school deans where their students matched. Then the next day, the residencies get informed. And the day after that is Match Day.

The NRMP writes a letter for each student, saying simply whether they've matched, and if so, where they've matched. All of these letters get sent to the medical schools. On Match Day, all the students participating in the match gather in one big room, do some retrospective stuff, have a toast, and listen to a short speech or two - but really everyone is waiting for their letter. So at 1145 this morning, they started passing out letters, one by one. Everyone was two steps from freaking out the entire time - this is the next few years of your life and maybe your entire career that you're about to see for the first time! - and at 1200, everyone tears open their letters all at the same time.

I had the advantage of being one of the few third years in the room and the scene lived up to every expectation. There was this sound of the mass tearing of envelopes, then whoops, and yells, and everyone was talking at once. Some people started crying, some were jumping up and down, some were just quietly pleased, or dumbfounded... it was incredible.

My girlfriend - she was really nervous - slowly edged open her envelope, eased the letter out, and then leaped out her chair with this yelp of joy: she'd gotten her number one choice! We're gonna be going to North Carolina!


Monday, March 17, 2008

Peds Neuro

So if all goes as planned, I'll be a pediatric neurologist in seven or eight years.

Ha!

Seriously, pediatric neurology. Sort of a strange choice (judging by most people's reactions.) Of course the surgeons all asked what I want to be when I grow up, and every time I said peds neuro, I got pretty horrible reactions like "What makes you want to do that to yourself?" or "Oh God..." or simply "Why?" Most everybody else glazes over immediately - it's a hell of a conversation killer. Most people seem to be thinking, "What the hell is that?"

Well, I'll tell you (ha!)

Basically, it's anything to do with the brain, nerves, and muscles of kids. That can be anything from multiple sclerosis to traumatic injury to metabolic disorders to (rarely) even stroke. Cerebral palsy, neuromuscular disorders, headaches, tics - all these are part of neurology. It's a wide and fascinating field. The real fun is in the neuro exam. Most of the physical exam skills we learn are rather direct. You listen to the heart, you palpate the liver, you feel the pulse, or look at the pharynx. The neuro exam is different. It's much more like a conversation between you and the person's brain, in which you do something particular and see how the nervous system responds. And it's all quite arcane. For instance, there's a phenomenon called "pass-pointing." This shows up when the doctor holds up their finger, and asks you to touch it with the tip of your finger, then touch your nose. When you touch your nose, they move their finger and you have to touch it again, then your nose, then the finger which has moved again. People with dysfunction of their cerebellum will "pass-point," which means they'll miss when they try to touch the doctor's finger. So with that simple maneuver, I can talk to your cerebellum. There are a multitude of signs like this one, with which I can speak to all of the different portions of the fantastic apparatus that is your nervous system.

The really difficult aspect of peds neuro, though is that many of these disorders can't be effectively treated. The running joke about neurologists is that they can diagnose anything but can treat nothing, and as much as that's silly it's actually pretty true to life. MS sucks. Duchenne sucks. Myotonic dystrophy sucks. Metabolic disorders really, really suck. And as a peds neurologist, part of my job is going to be telling kids and their parents how life is going to be pretty hard, despite everything medicine has to offer. I won't lie - it's a daunting challenge that I can't claim to even understand yet.

There's hope, though. Scientific interest in neurology is blooming, and new advances are made every year. I've wanted for a long time to be on the cutting edge, to be discovering new ground - what better way than to enter a field with so much potential for new discovery?
Maybe that's kind of pie-in-the-sky. But there are downsides to any medical field. Surgeons sacrifice their entire lives on the altar of the OR. Dermatologists have to look at skin all day long. ER docs get dumped on by everyone in the hospital. And neurologists diagnose diseases for which there may be no effective treatment. But at the same time, they are the only people equipped to deal with those diseases in any meaningful way.

And if you're going to take on that kind of responsibility, you ought to love the work from the basics on up. And I do.


Had a bit of a scare today. I thought that I'd already missed the deadline to apply for peds neuro programs, as on the website the listed deadline is January 25, 2008. Boy did I feel like an idiot. But then I looked a little harder and saw that this deadline comes after the Dean's Letters are to have been released. So I'm guessing their website just isn't updated yet. Whew. I guess if I'm still going to be the Absent-Minded Professor, I can at least be proactively absent-minded. Or something.

Saturday, March 1, 2008

In like a lion

So surgery is coming to a close soon. I have only one day of actual work left. How's that? Literally, I needn't ever step into an OR ever again unless I decide I want to. And I don't think I'm going to miss it. Don't get me wrong - it's a tremendous privilege afforded to few, and yes, one that I've earned - but I just ain't no surgeon.

The interns (who rotate between surgical services every month) switched out this past Friday. What's nice about the interns rotating is that the resident previously on night float is going to be on the peds service. Sweeet. He's already let me do pretty much as I please, and I've gotten to see a couple of surgeries, help out on the wards, see some patients and (heh) blog a little. Tomorrow should be good. I'll see some procedures, I'll help out on the floor, and I'll get my time in. And then I'll be done.

Call on Friday was busy, else I would have probably given the weekly on-call update. Got to see a nice couple of cases. My favorite was the poor guy who came in real messed up after a bar fight. I feel bad for the guy, but he was the classic drunk trauma case. Bloody, beaten up, loudly proclaiming his sobriety, and puking his guts out. He was pretty pitiful, especially when the cops came into the trauma bay to take pictures of his injuries (more than a little smugly, I might add.) I had planned to study and sleep (as I've had the time previously) but we got the right number of cases at appropriate intervals, and I got about two good hours in.

Seeing as it's almost the end, highlights of the surgery rotation:
  • I walk into the neuro ICU on the first day of the rotation eating an energy bar. A resident sees me and says "Are you eating chocolate already? Where did you get that? Did you get that from the resident room? You shouldn't eat that!"

    My clerkship director says "You'd have to be a damn fool to want to be a surgeon, and you look smarter than that." Yes I do.

    Seeing an one of the neurosurgery attendings I&D a staggering head trauma.

    The chief of neurosurgery instructed me to make the initial incision on my first day.

    The classic drunk guy shows up to trauma, loudly proclaiming himself sober as he pukes into a basin that (being the good medical student) I am holding.

    Operating with the head of surgery, who let me sew because I answered a question about Top Gun without hesitation.

    My Auburn grad resident - war damn eagle!

    My little girl on total peripheral nutrition, who got used to me coming in early and would give me a little smile and open her mouth so I could check her mucous membranes (sounds worse than it is.)

    An Amish girl with tuberous sclerosis, who arrived in her Amish garb and a pair of delightfully tacky sunglasses (for her photophobia.)

    In ENT Peds clinic, we have what are essentially dentist's chairs for the patients to sit in, so they can be examined more closely. When he pushed the button to raise the chair, one of my residents would tell the kids that if they didn't tell him to stop, they'd go right through the ceiling. One kid looked absolutely terrified.

    The NP told me a story about how they'll take sick residents in the back of clinic and hook them up to IV's so they can keep working. She said she gave one resident three liters before she sent him home, and one of the attendings still thought he should tough it out.

    I'm whistling on the wards. My cool resident (a big gamer) looks up and says "Sounds like the chocobo song..."

    Diagnosing and forming a correct plan for an umbilical hernia in an asymptomatic one year old. I'm (almost like) a doctor now!

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Call night again. My resident (again) cut me loose as a goose. Tonight will probably be much busier because we got a critical mass of snow. What do I mean by critical mass? Just enough snow to make the roads funky, but just little enough to seem cheery and inviting. Much less, and it's basically rain. Much more, and either the roads are plowed or no one is willing to brave the weather. Except the crazy ones, but we'd get the crazy ones anyway.

I was talking to another med student (a guy who knows his stuff and takes care of business) and he expressed the same sort of difficulty with not having a role and not knowing how to fight for the role that we don't know what it is. He says, we're basically paid observers but hey! We're payin' out the nose for this! Granted, it is an intense privilege. But it's still frustrating just to watch. And no one really seems to understand what we want - to be part of the team. No, worse than that - they say "Be part of the team!" And I have little idea how, most of the time. And that wears you down. Forget the long hours standing, the 0400 wake up. It's most tiring to push against something that doesn't even know you're pushing.

I'm really tired. Maybe it's just surgery... but I'm worn out. And not really physically, or mentally - I sleep enough and I feel fine. I'm just tired.

And I feel like everything's suffering because of that. For one, I began this blog with lofty goals and most of what I write about is medical school. I haven't written in weeks, and I almost didn't do anything for Valentine's Day. Luckily, I have a spectacular girlfriend who is immensely understanding.

And that's why I can't do surgery. I can be a surgeon. I am capable of doing it for the rest of my life, 24-7-365. It's interesting, it's important, and it's a challenge. But surgery flat-out eats you up. And I don't want that. We had a lecture from this one attending, who was telling us that he gets real excited any time he gets to open up the neck and play in the carotid sheath. And then he pauses and says, "If you aren't getting those kind of feelings when you think about operating, you shouldn't be a surgeon." I just don't get those kind of feelings. That, I think, is a very important lesson that this rotation has taught me. I'm just not a surgeon.

But in a broader sense, I'm going to try and focus on things other than med school in this space. It's cathartic but not enriching to moan about med school all the time (and frankly it makes me sound pretty spoiled, boo-hoo I get to do surgery all day.) Maybe once in a while if something interesting happens. But it's everything else that I'm going to make more important.

Saturday, February 16, 2008

Live and lea-

Med school (seemingly) is all about learning in what seems to be the least efficient way possible. For instance, the first two years, you spend most of your time in the classroom* learning from PhD's who want you to learn what they enjoy. Then you spend 2-3 months fearfully cramming into your brain all the information that the writers of the USMLE want you to know (which may or may not be what the PhD's want you to know.) Then you get out on the wards and it's a whole new ballgame, son.

No one teaches you how to actually be a member of a medical team and that's a damn shame. I can tell you that for some people, sphingomyelin is very important. I can tell you that if the boards show a picture of a funny-looking guy with his hands held beside his face, it's probably a growth hormone-oma of the pituitary. But I'm having a hard time telling you how to actually take care of another human being. It just isn't taught.

I think there are two reasons for that. The first of which is, there just isn't time. They tell us the first day that there is too much information to learn in the four years we are given and we can't do it if we try, but we're expected to try. They can't teach you about the hospital because you don't yet know what sphingomyelin is. The second reason is, there's no possible way to do that. Every service in the hospital operates differently. And among services with the same aim, every hospital is different. There just ain't no way.

Which is why I kind of shrug when my intern's eyes bug out as I say "I only went to pediatric traumas last night." I'm rotating through peds surgery right now, so I think, when I'm on call I go to the peds stuff - right? Wrong. When I'm on call during my peds rotation, I go to pediatric AND adult traumas. For some reason my intern thinks this should be self-evident. I don't much mind. I had a real, real quiet night and I got a ton of reading done. Maybe next time.

Live and learn, you know? Except not really. An attending was talking to me about just that, learning theory. There's a method to learning medicine called "See one, do one, teach one." And it's as simple as that. See a procedure, do it yourself, teach it to someone else. My attending says to me, that's a system designed to propagate errors. The real way to do it is see it, do it, see it again, do it again, etc. That way you see it, then you do it (realizing what you are actually doing,) and then you see it again with eyes open. But that doesn't really work in an environment in which your role changes constantly. And that's the difficulty here - knowing one's role.

Surgery can be pretty good for that. For instance, in the OR I have a very simple role as a helper. I help retract during surgery (if needed,) I bring in the bed when the surgery is over, and I write the operative note at the end. Ultimately that's all that is required to be a good medical student. Anything after that is up to me... but what role am I to take? I feel like I know just enough to cover a dime if it isn't windy.

So I don't feel too bad about going to the lone pediatric trauma last night, and reading instead. If I'm going to feel comfortable taking a hand, I've got to be more confident in what I know. If the efficient way to do that is just to sit down and do it, I'm doing it.

And it was kind of fun to sit up and read, read, read. Haven't done that in a long time. Unfortunately, I had to drink so much caffeine that by the time the morning came around, I was literally nauseous. Yet another example of med school's pervading themes: learn about being a healthy person, but don't immediately apply much of that knowledge to yourself.


*Others did. I spent most of my time out of class, in my room. With my books.

Friday, February 15, 2008

Adenovirus.

It's high flu season. And I've gotten some foreboding reports.

First of all, I caught a wicked good flu last weekend. And not just a rhinovirus, a real honest-to-God hates-your-guts influenza. Rocked me right in the face. For folks who don't know, most people who say they have the flu don't actually have the flu. They've got a rhino, a corona, or some other virus that makes you feel crappy, and you might go home or you might soldier through work after all. The flu ain't like that. Influenza gives you body aches and intense malaise - you just can't do anything. You sit around hurting for at least a couple days with a brain that feels like marshmallow fluff. You'll probably get pretty dehydrated, what with the fevers. Lord knows I did. My girlfriend said my lips were the color of my even-paler-than-normal face. And then she went and got me a pile of Gatorade and made me some soup - she's pretty awesome like that.

But it was also good on her account because (surprise!) she came down with the exact same thing while I was convalescing. We chowed down on some good wonton soup and lo mein that night (surprisingly good sick food...)

Long story short: you remember the flu. It does not play around.

Now, even though we got knocked flat on our butts with the flu, it wasn't anywhere close to killing us. But there are some people whom it does kill, chiefly the very young, the elderly, and people with weak immune systems - 36,000 a year in America alone. To make the obligatory bizarre comparison: HIV kills around 20,000 people every year in the USA (according to the CDC.) Eh?

Perhaps the plural of "anecdote" isn't "evidence"... but everyone I know seems to have gotten laid out by the flu. And now I hear that my girlfriend's old alma mater is closing up for a little while because too many students and faculty have gotten too sick. Keep in mind that the flu shot didn't work this year*, another nasty thing about adenovirus - sometimes it moves too fast genetically for our vaccines to keep up.

Maybe my concern also has something to do with having watched "Children of Men" recently, a premise of which is that the world went to hell after the flu pandemic of 2008.

Wash your hands and cough into your elbows. The fertility of the human race is depending on you.



*Makes me feel like less of a dumbass for being the asthmatic on steroids who "just didn't get" a flu shot. Only a little less.

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

It's virus season

[Written sometime in the fall, remembered just the other day.]

As third-year medical students, we spend our fall and spring semesters rotating through various medical specialties - surgery, medicine, pediatrics, OB/GYN, psychiatry, family medicine, etc. - so we can have some small clue as to what we want to practice. Currently, I'm on pediatrics, and I love it for the most part. I was small-talking with the NP I'm working with this week, and we got to wondering why Thanksgiving is so close to Christmas. I'm beginning to think it's because of this little booger:

I hate viruses and rhinovirus tops my list. It's rhino and RSV season here, and if Thanksgiving and Christmas were farther apart it would be depressing. I picked up a little somethin' somethin' from the kiddies last week and it's really rocking my world. That's the joy of pediatrics - getting innoculated with the latest respiratory viruses. Then, you're immune for the rest of the year. I guess that's one of the joys of pediatrics. Long story short, I've been pretty miserable. It started Sunday night, and has only gathered speed since then. Maybe the fact that I got up at 0400 Monday morning to come back to my rotation didn't help, but that wasn't entirely my fault what with the first slush/snow hitting us on Sunday night and 70-something miles of highway separating my home apartment and the hospital where I'm rotating. Monday was bad, but not so bad until the evening when the fever started. I slept ten hours into Tuesday and felt worse, and only made it through the morning thanks to a fellow med student's gift of cough medicine - and even still, I just couldn't focus. Brain was all fuzzy. In the afternoon I slugged some cough syrup to no avail. My NP looked at me and said "Go home - we won't tattle on you."

Any other med school, and I don't think that simple reassurance would have meant so much. But at my institution (which shall remain unnamed) it means something. If my course directors got word of my skipping out this afternoon, I'd have associate deans leaping down my throat in a heartbeat. It's just not the sort of thing that is tolerated, even if I'm febrile and have my hands full just not infecting my patients with whatever lovely bug I've contracted.

Mind you, this is the same institution that sent not one, not two, but four emails in two weeks to the students - CC'd to the course directors - explaining that the day after Thanksgiving is not a holiday. And scheduled lectures for that Friday afternoon. And, scheduled them at 1400 so that we could return to our clerkship site the day after Thanksgiving, work the morning, then drive back to our home institution for those aforementioned lectures. Thankfully, my clerkship site told us that we have no clinical responsibilities for the day after Thanksgiving and put it in writing. I just have the misfortune of having lectures that Friday. But for my unluckier classmates, it means they're stuck here for that day, and if the folks aren't close by, they don't get to see their families until Christmas. Better figure out how to make a turkey on your own.

I know that I'm a fortunate son with a silver spoon in my mouth, and I'm extremely fortunate to be in med school at all. But in all reality, physicians get sick, physicians visit their families on Thanksgiving, and physicians are able to plan this all in advance. And, while I'm not a physician yet, I'm paying out the nose for all this. I graduated from college with a degree in biomedical engineering, and gave up the promise of a career in that field to enter medical school. Here's a comparison of my financial status now to what it could have been:


For $50,000 into the red every year, I'd like a little more input into my holiday schedule. What's more: while physicians are handsomely paid, the average doctor's salary isn't enough to compensate for the lost investment time in which they're A. accruing a towering pile of debt, or B. paying off their loans. If you go to college, get a good job once you get out, and manage your money well, you actually do better than the average doctor in the long run. Don't even get me started on plumbers. You could say that people who go into medicine just for the money either don't understand finance, or are brilliant and will do interventional radio or plastics and will be millionaires some day. Neither of which is me. So why shouldn't I be an engineer? The money's better, the hours are great.


Or hell, why not be a Marine? Boot camp only lasts three months, and you certainly don't pay for it. I've taken to wondering what that would be like, since so much of med school seems like mental retraining.


The second stage of boot camp includes an exercise called "the crucible."

The crucible is the culmination of everything a basic rifleman Marine should know. It is three days of constant strenuous testing, humping, hardship, punishment, and starvation. The recruit is given two field stripped MRE's (Meaning all thats left is the main meal and side meals, taking away any candy, condiments, and such), and this is meant to supply them for the next three days. Worthy of note, is that while some recruits have food to spare at the end of this ordeal, others consume their rations quickly, and when they become hungry, other recruits aid their fellows, some even giving their last bit of food to another. This is one of the goals of the crucible: to train marines to look out for one another. This also distinguishes leaders among the recruits, something the Drill Instructors look for in their platoons. The crucible consists of certain challenges for the recruits, broken into platoons, to accomplish as a whole, or failed as a whole. One single recruit completing an obstacle means almost nothing. If anyone fails, it means that those that completed it failed to aid their fellow recruit in the accomplishment of their given mission.
source

Maybe we don't have MRE's, but we do have acetaminophen and guiafenesin.