GROTUS' ACORN

God girl grill gridiron
Showing posts with label college football. Show all posts
Showing posts with label college football. Show all posts

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Method for Quantifying Whole-Team Performance

The question is, what’s the best way to look at a team’s performance on the whole? We basically have three important units by which we measure a football squad. The first – and most ultimately important – is the scoreboard. The second is yards, either yards given up by the defense or yards claimed by the offense. And the third is turnovers. Being an engineer and seeing three units, my impulse is to combine the three into some useful metric. According to this article at Sports Quant, fumbles and interceptions both result in about the same amount of lost points or yards. Smart Football reader Brad Eccles makes the case that fifty yards is a statistically-reasonable penalty for either a fumble or interception – that is, if you fumble, subtract fifty from your offensive yardage total. I’ve also seen (though I can not remember where, so let me know if you run across that number or a better one) that fifty yards is an appropriate bonus for plays that result in a touchdown. This seems about right to me. Thus, we can convert turnovers and touchdowns into yards and express a team’s production using a single unit. Moreover, what’s good for me is bad for my opponent and vice-versa: penalties against Auburn should be recorded as negative yards, and penalties against opponents as positive yards.

This includes the offense and the defense: the offense’s forward progress can be expressed as positive yardage, and the defense’s as negative yardage. As we learned last year, the offense and defense are not distinct.

I’ve borrowed another idea from Smart Football. There, he describes a method of evaluating a play’s success called the Sharpe Ratio. Now, I have my own issues with the Sharpe ratio – dividing by standard deviation is not a good idea when, in particular, most running backs’ success depends on their big-play potential. However, one important thing contained in that statistic is the evaluation of a play in comparison to its risk. We could theoretically run a short screen, a slant, or a quarterback draw every single play and gain a dependable, undefendable two yards every single time. While this would not be an effective strategy, all plays must be evaluated against this standard. For instance, an incomplete pass is essentially two yards given up forever. Thus, the yardage that results from each play is adjusted down by two.

I usually make some judgment about what constitutes “garbage time” and ignore that yardage. If one team is clearly bleeding clock, they’ve essentially stopped running their offense and it shouldn’t count. Also, I ignore what I consider to be uncoachable plays or dumb luck, like interceptions returned for touchdowns – these don’t count as an interception and a touchdown, just as one or the other. If the defense gets the ball, they’ve won and a win is worth fifty. Same thing for special teams touchdowns.

By this method, we can chart out our team’s progress over the entire game, in both phases of the game, as a single function. This is just what I’ve done. I copy the play-by-play at ESPN.com (more reliable than Rivals) into a text file, import that text file into a spreadsheet, and use the wonders of MS Excel to semi-automatically create a running list of the plays that are run, the players who run them, the down, the distance, the location and the result. Then, once I have an adjusted yardage for each play, I graph a running sum of offensive and defensive yards – this is essentially a running, risk-adjusted yardage differential. It gives some idea of the arc and flow of the game, and unites the offense’s and defense’s statistics. The goal, obviously, is to be in the positive by the last whistle. Granted, this does not reliably correlate with a team winning the game – field goals, defensive touchdowns, and special teams touchdowns are not included. But that’s not the point – I just want to see which team is most effective when they get down to work.

(I originally posted this at The War Eagle Reader, where you can see the results.)

Friday, August 14, 2009

What else is in the teaches of Peaches? Todd is the starter. Huh? Wha?

pretty stunned


I woke up this morning and loaded up my run of sports sites in Firefox. As usual, I end up skipping to THABOTN because Jay's videos auto-play and they start off with that goofy music. "This again," I think to myself. "I'll just shut that off." Thus my day begins: as your body grows bigger, your mind must flower, it's great to learn 'cause knowledge is power! Chris Todd: starting QB despite missing spring drills. Is make joke Jay G. because no funny!

But then I played through the video, in which Kodi gamely answers question after question with no waver in his voice but an expression that says didn't you hear me say I'm going to go pray about this?


Ever to conquer, never to yield.

You have to say this of the guy - and I agree with the Chiznik - he's resilient. Chris Todd is going nowhere until they make him go. Shoulder? Shoulder shmoulder. Mentor ousted mid-season? Still a tiger. Missed spring practice? He'd rather be there for two-a-days anyway. And by God, that kind of persistence is bound to pay off. So my hat's off to him.

I can't speak for his arm, but as I remember - and I can't be bothered to dig up the post at THABOTN - folks have been complaining about him stinging fingers all summer practice. Maybe his shoulder's finally back to it's original, Favre-ian levels. I sure hope so. I really, really hope so.


Stay in school cause it's the best.

In that first moment of incredulity, I was tempted to write something snide and/or panicky. Sure would have been easy. But the fact of the matter is that Franklin heavily favored Todd and has since high school, Mike Leach at one point named him heir to the Red Raider stat sheet, Tuberville let him split reps with our then-heir-apparent, and now Malzahn is also buying in. Franklin, I could dismiss as a Svengali. Tuberville, I could believe he just didn't have his head in the game. Leach, I could contend that he made that decision prior to Todd's shoulder injury. But when Malzahn names Todd the starter after only seeing him in summer ball... there's just got to be something there. Maybe, just maybe, I don't know as much as Malzahn, Leach, and Franklin put together.

So given the consensus of experts, I'm going to consider this issue settled and hold my tongue at least through our first drive versus La-Tech. But just for good measure... at some point last season, we were left with this distinct impression:


By all accounts, the arm is back. Let's put one of those beefy arms back on him for good measure:


Alright now.

Spread Eagle 2009

One thing we know for sure is that this is not going to be a spread a la West Virginia or Florida with the constant threat of a running quarterback. As we discovered almost immediately last season, Chris Todd can't sell the zone read because he can't run fast enough to challenge SEC defenders - the defense chases the tailback because they know they can react to the white boy, and what we end up with is a play-action quarterback draw. With a slow, slow quarterback. The sheer crazy-like-a-fox surprise Todd draw worked a couple times versus LSU, but that won't last long. Todd will get his bell rung and we'll be back to square one minus our anointed starter.

So I expect that while we will be a spread offense, we won't be a Pat White, Tim Tebow, Terrell Pryor, Colin Kaepernick, etc. type of spread offense. We'll spread the field from under center and run out of ace sets or a three-wide I-form. Perhaps picking Todd lends some credence to the coaching staff's insistence that we'll truly be a smash-mouth running team.

Kodi

They're repping him at wideout... How on earth is he going to see the field if he is a freshman-quality wideout in his junior year of college? Even if we were a team that planned to rotate receivers, no one becomes a crisp route-runner overnight. Either Trooper Taylor has been smoke-screening his receivers with his effusions of praise - such that a previously-starting quarterback has a reasonable chance to compete - or Kodi has one year to get better than the guys who've already been doing it for two.

I don't know what's going through his head right now, but if I was recruited as a quarterback, played as a true freshman quarterback, contested for the starting job as quarterback the following year and into the spring and then suddenly was moved out of the backfield entirely, I'd be wondering how valuable I was to the team. Burns reportedly said "I'm mature enough to handle this." To be honest, Kodi, I'm a 26-year-old married doctor and I don't know if I'd be mature enough to handle that.

The other possibility is that Kodi is going to be a wildcat wingback/receiver - basically, a dedicated reverse-passer. In which case, he is now by default competing with Super Mario for touches. If I was either of those guys, I'd be looking at this situation and saying "What the hell?" How is it that two of the most physically gifted players on our team are also its most homeless? Why are we making our gene-pool lotto winners into hobos and then makin' 'em fight? What I think would be most depressing is if one of them wins - the other would be essentially a wasted talent, and wasted time. Especially if Kodi wins: he'd be re-demoted from starting QB to gimmick-in-service-of-the-alabaster-statue. Surely there must be a way to get both of these guys reliable positions. Surely.

I must not know an awful lot. War Damn Eagle.

Wednesday, June 10, 2009

Gridiron Skew Part 1

Something you have already guessed: your humble blogger is a bit of a nerd. And, I really nerd out on football. It is a great sporting frontier of obstinate complexity. Twenty-two men with different, overlapping and constantly fluctuating jobs operate from a multitude of formations on a field that, conceptually, is massive, continental, vast. This is no pitcher-vs-batter game, is not even as simple as basketball. Football is to other sports as chess is to checkers.

So naturally, it's exciting to an amateur mathnerd like myself to see that folks out there on the intertubes are trying to make sense of the pile of data generated by each single football game. Granted, some of this is of the "We calculate this metric from a privileged position" variety, or baldly dismissive of core mathematical concepts1. But Chris Brown of Smart Football really digs up some gems, and he's more than willing to tantalize us with his methods. He talks about game theory and its application to run/pass balance. He mentions the Sharpe ratio when evaluating the effectiveness of a play. Every step wrings a little more heuristics out of the great game. This, my friends, is awesome.

For instance, the aforementioned Sharpe ratio. As Chris puts it:
The Sharpe Ratio is defined as the ratio of the difference between the expected return of some strategy minus the expected return of some riskless benchmark and the standard deviation of the strategy.

[ed: This can be written as such for those of us who like equations]

Standard deviation is a measurement of the volatility of a set of values. You can read more about standard deviation here. For example, if a given pass play was run four times, and the results (in yards) of the play was 10, 10, 10, and 10, it has a standard deviation of 0. However, if it was run four times and the results were 0, 0, 40, and 0, it has the same average gain (10 yards) but its standard deviation would be 20. We would prefer pass play one to pass play two. It has the same expected gain, but it is less risky than the second.

This is all well and good. What's more, the Sharpe ratio may be used to determine the ratio with which you use one strategy (or one play) over another. If one play's Sharpe ratio is 2 and the other play's Sharpe ratio is 4, you should use the latter play twice as often as the former. The power of this method is clear when you begin sectioning your data ever more finely - the Sharpe ratio allows us to compare any number of situations. How do your different running plays fare on second down and less than five yards? Out of which formation is play-action most effective? At what position on the field is your offense most able to run the HB draw to the near side out of a pro set in the fourth quarter on third down with more than four yards to go? With enough data, the Sharpe ratio can help you answer that question.

However, the Sharpe ratio is weak in a critical aspect: it punishes inconsistency. Why is that a weakness? Take, for example, the first pass play postulated: absolute, robotic 10 yards per attempt. Sounds like a great play. What could be better, though, is a play that results in a 20 yard gain every fourth attempt (10, 10, 10, 20.) It's clear to everyone and their blind, demented uncle that 10, 10, 10, 20 is better than 10, 10, 10, 10. And yet, the Sharpe ratio is misleading. Because we divide by standard deviation, a play's inconsistency - whether the play succeeds wildly or fails miserably - is punished. Essentially, when you calculate the Sharpe ratio, you are implicitly assuming that an offensive big play and a defensive big play are equally horrible. This weakness becomes especially clear when one starts adjusting yardage totals for touchdowns and turnovers. A helpful guy out on the interwebs has run the calculations: a touchdown or a turnover is basically equivalent to 50 yards. But if your goal line play wins you a touchdown every fourth attempt - certainly an effective play - that's 1, 1, 1, and 51. Standard deviation is so high that it will obliterate your statistical decision-making.

I'm picking on the Sharpe ratio because its promises are so tantalizing, and yet I think it asks the wrong question. What we should be ascertaining is the level of skew in the yards gained by each play. Aside perhaps from Jim Tressel, coaches value big-play capability just as much as they dread the defense's ability to ram a big play down their throat. We all want our teams to be explosive. Just, explosive in the downfield direction. To put it in the terms of the shape of a distribution, we want the yards-per-play distribution to have a negative skew, like so (via): Skew answers the question, does a play regularly succeed? If there is negative skew, the answer is yes. So how do we reward negative skew in our analyses?

I should probably put the rest in another post...




1. Direct quote:
I do agree ... that R-squared gives you "the proportion of variance that is in common between NBA team payroll and NBA team performance." But what does that mean? Almost nothing, unless you're a statistician.
Similarly, one could declare that "I do agree that USC hammered the seams in Penn State's overmatched cover 3 defense, but what does that mean? Almost nothing, unless you're talking about football." May as well come out and say "I don't understand how to use this metric but I'm going to criticize it."

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

PSA for all our friendly fliers


This fall, if you are flying in the general area of Auburn University on a Saturday night, please take care to divert your Cessna around Jordan-Hare Stadium. We would hate to chip the paint.




War Damn Eagle.

Friday, January 30, 2009

I stand double-corrected

You may recall some certain family lore I shared with the intertubes last fall (hint: Phillip Marshall's mustache) and subsequently had to correct. Well, the whole story is even more clear now, thanks to my Mom who wrote me some time ago to further elucidate:

Before it becomes some family legend that Dad met me at Auburn, Dad and I met at work, when I was a secretary at the State of Alabama, Estate Tax Dept. I was an Alabama fan at the time, raised by Granddaddy in the family tradition. Only Uncle Lamar was an Auburn fan at the time that I know of, and we considered him "strange." They never won!! How could he be for the losers?

Anyway, Dad and I dated 3 years and I gradually shifted alliances, threw away a lot of red clothes. Then Dad went off to pursue his degree at Auburn. He had 2 years remaining. We got married in 1979 during Christmas break, and that's when I went to Auburn...

Whatever possessed us to start a family in college, with absolutely no money or Dad even having a real job, was just the exuberance of youthful optimism. So you are the product of Dad's and my blind faith, eternal optimism and joyous spirit of living dirt poor but in the loving arms of AU. It's a wonder, though, your name is not "Bo".
My father remarked that had he been so inclined, my name would have been Vincent.

It's true, by the by, that my family is weirdly split between Auburn and Alabama fans. And moreso, this Romeo-and-Juliet tale isn't evenly divided between the two marrying clans - there are Auburn and Bama fans intermingling on either side. That's made for some interesting conversations the past six years. But hey, being Auburn Tigers, we are about family if nothing else.

War Damn Eagle!

As good a day as any

What a Year

I may have - no, absolutely I have - picked the weirdest season possible in which to begin writing about Auburn football. From the Tony Franklin hire to 3-2 to ChrisToddGate to Spread Man Walking to Zombie Nallsminger to Tubby Fired and Chizik Hired to Gustav to the inexplicable firing of Clinton Durst... I can't remember any season in which college football as a whole left me so bewildered. With signing day approaching fast, it's safe to say that things absolutely must cool down soon. There just isn't any drama left in the tank.

Count this as the first February in a long, long time that comes welcome. We're about to enter the desolation of an offseason desert, and I for one am breathing a sigh of relief - I've got sensory overload from all the frogs, rivers of blood, boils, hail, locusts, pillars of cloud and fire, and armies drowned in collapsing seas. Here's to boredom. I'm sure I'll change my tune in another few weeks.


"The Wheel of Time turns, and Ages come and pass, leaving memories that become legend. Legend fades to myth, and even myth is long forgotten when the Age that gave it birth comes again."

What's so special about Benton, Illinois? For one, it was named for Senator Thomas Hart Benton:

You don't mess with Thomas Hart Benton

Benton was an accomplished dueler. As an attorney in Missouri, one of his rivals Charles Lucas challenged him to a duel on Bloody Island. The cause? Each had accused the other of lying. They squared off and fired. Benton was grazed in the knee but shot his opponent through the throat at thirty paces. He absolved his opponent from finishing the duel. However, murmers were heard that, being a crack shot, Benton rigged the duel to his own talents. So, he challenged the defeated Lucas to a rematch and shot him through the heart from a mere nine feet.

This is the kind of man we need. A man who took a principled stand against slavery when his party and the state he adopted were increasingly pro-slavery. A man who would go nose-to-nose with Andrew Jackson and not blink. A man who fought for the farmer and the frontiersman as long as they would work the rich American soil. A man who will shoot you dead from nine feet or ninety feet if you call him a liar. Thomas Hart Benton would be the exact counter to Saban's coachbotting: no less deadly an opponent, no less steely-nerved, but noble in his devotion to the individual and to the worth of work - hard work.

What else makes Benton unique? Well, here's Benton, Illinois:

View Larger Map

And here's Benton with the superimposed route from Ames to Auburn (or Auburn to Ames):

View Larger Map

That's right - almost exactly halfway as the U-Haul rolls. Hopefully, as the coaching wheel swung these two coaches between Iowa and Alabama, they could feel some influence from that man whose name lies at the hub. They're gonna need it.

Thursday, January 22, 2009

Okay What?

...really, what?

I was still basking in the glory of our Christmas windfall. The Malzahn-Taylor coup. What the hell is happening on the plains? I leave the blAUgosphere for a few weeks and this is what happens.


First: the guy I don't miss.

This (courtesy of the JCCW.)


Now I'm not one to assign all sorts of moral imperatives to the coaching of college football. It's a business, bottom-to-top. The players are there either to be millionaires or to get college paid for. The coaches are there to be millionaires. The stadiums are there to provide the millions. And even more than that - without the millions, the young men who have the talent simply don't have access to the kinds of facilities and staff to even make use of that talent. Without the money, there is no football as we know it. No Michael Crabtree. No Reggie Bush. No Jordan-Hare. The whole system is steroidized by the sordid grubbing of money at all phases of the game. No illusions here, folks. Ayn Rand would be tickled pink (if she could be such a thing.)

And yes, the green, well-grubbed heart of NCAA football does imply that all coaches are in some sense mercenaries. They're in football and not something else purely because they love football - I wager that if you took a bunch of business executives, football coaches, and cardiothoracic surgeons, scrubbed their resumes of all references to specific industries, and shuffled 'em up in a big pile... no one could tell the difference. Assistants especially. While a head coach could find the right place to settle down for a legacy-building longhaul, no boy ever dreamed of growing up to run half a football team the rest of his life. They're all hunting the next big thing, looking for the next stepping stone to a bigger future and a bigger paycheck. In the immortal words of Dwight Schrute,
Would I ever leave this company? Look, I'm all about loyalty. In fact, I feel like part of what I'm being paid for here is my loyalty. But if there were somewhere else that valued loyalty more highly, I'm going wherever they value loyalty the most
For the successful guys, the real eye-on-the-prize movers, that also means they've probably got the next step planned out long in advance. At least, they've got to have the general idea hashed out. Think Muschamp, Gibbs and Rhoads didn't at some point remember Chizik's leap to the media-friendly digs at Texas in choosing to come to Auburn? Think again. Muschamp is heir to the throne of Longhorn and Rhoads has a coaching gig practically in his home town. Seems to have worked out the way they'd hoped.

What really sucks is that Willis has probably been thinking about leaving for a long time. Hanging out with the BBQ Crew is bound to take its toll on any upwardly mobile, dedicated coach. In fact, it's likely only to accentuate that mercenary tendency that drives these guys to do what they do. Moreover, I can see how position coaches such as Willis would never be able to make the next jump when the head coordinator has been jumping off so often lately. It's like trying to jump off a trampoline in the split seconds between Andre the Giant, Casey Hampton, and Dog the Bounty Hunter making their farewell leaps. I guess he didn't want to take his chances, with the next gorilla probably using him as a springboard, too. If I was him, I would probably take the first good opportunity1 to make my own way. In this sense, Willis is simply the last rat to jump ship from the HMS Live To Punt.

All's needed is for Saban to play a little Mephistopheles to Faustus James and boom! A back is forever turned. And as such, I can't entirely blame Willis for leaving. But that still leaves the question of why James Willis bailed for the Tide. The only conclusion that I can come to is, he doesn't think it makes much of a difference whom he solicits.

I've struggled to say exactly why - outside of Auburn-ness2 - that matters so much. The only way I can really address it is through the inevitable comparisons that have circled through the blAUgosphere. He's not, as some suggested, Cypher: Cypher wanted out of the game entirely. And he's not really Lando, either: Lando wasn't given any choice in betraying his friends. It honestly matters to me that Willis would leave our institution, a place that has been home to him for years and years, only to willingly embrace our enemy. The best comparison, I think, is Sal Tessio. Willis was, after all, a great soldier. He even bad-mouthed the Tide program to recruits, like, less than a week ago. But I guess he was too smart.


"Tell Mike it was only business."

Don't get me wrong - college football is not the Mafia, and Saban, really, is no Don Barzini. But the same complex regionalism, the deep sense of terroir and historical justice and injustice that burn in Sicilia, those same things saturate college football and make it the sport of America. Nothing else expresses our particular national pride and fervor quite like the sport played on Saturdays. It's why college players are all amateurs, why we have honest-to-God fight songs that people actually play and sing, why we hate Bama, why I can hardly stand to see the Crimson Tide on the field playing anybody, why people like me say "we" when they refer to a team they've never played on and will never seriously affect. It's that blinding, clenched devotion to family that made a Don Corleone out of Michael, and yet it's the reason why The Godfather is so compelling. These ferocious, violent people are so deeply sympathetic because they cling so tightly to one another with that that unspeakable, fervent, gnawing us-ness that drove our very ancestors to these shores.

And James Willis - who has been sheltered by his alma mater for more than a decade as an athlete and a teacher - doesn't think it matters. Moreover, he doesn't seem to think any of it really matters, except on the recruiting warpath. What kind of talk is he going to talk about Auburn next year? What things did he say about Bama that he will he recycle into lies about us, to feed that next high school senior linebacker? Like Sal Tessio, he'd probably say that he does like us, likes Auburn, and appreciates all the good it's done him - it's just business. Business that left him behind, and business that led him to a Tuscaloosa welcome.

James Willis truly belongs where he landed and he doesn't belong at Auburn.

I'm with the rest of the blAUgosphere: good riddance. I can't wait for Malzahn to make your boys sprint back and forth across the field over and over and then hit 'em right in the mouth.


And next: the guy I fear we will miss for a very, very long time:



This is a decision I just can't understand. Why we let go of our starting punter is absolutely beyond my comprehension.

I can think of, basically, three reasons why you cut a college player's scholarship. The first is discipline and unless we're counting his propensity get sick once at a particularly bad time as misconduct, the guy squeaks.

The second is the "system." There are "system" wide receivers, running backs, linebackers, etc. If you plan to structure the offense around a guy like Jacquizz Rodgers and the guy competing for scholarships was struck from the mold of Ron Dayne, well, decisions might need making. But punters? What special teams strategy can not make use of a rocket-legged punters? FAA-defying walkons who soundly thump their pre-season all-SEC-as-sophomore competition and start every game but one? NASA-themed punters whose very presence could have won a hotly-contested heartbreaker in Death Valley? I mean, really, where are the X's and O's in this decision? There doesn't seem to be any strategic reason why Clinton Durst wasn't a keeper. No, more than that - a downright classic-Tuberville diamond in the rough.

The third is a Sabanistic cull, getting rid of the dead weight to make room for the blue chips. But if there was one single player on our team this past season who never once qualified as dead weight, it was Clinton "Saturn V" Durst. He could be more accurately described as "lynch pin" or "keystone" or "our entire special teams." Just for a moment consider the LSU game, and the cost to our season of that lone weekend of fever. How desperately we needed him, and how wrenchingly awful was our punting. And not only was it bad, it was despairingly terrible at the worst possible moment. And what gratitude we show now.

War Damn Eagle, Clinton Durst. The low-flying airplanes won't miss you but I sure will.




1 IE, the first time when Tommy Tuberville isn't looking you in the eye and saying "James, you're an Auburn man. Please, just stick around a little while longer and help us transition with this new guy."

2 Of course, the Auburn Family factor is no small thing. Or, if it isn't, then there is something very out of sync between the Auburn higher-ups and the rest of our nationwide community.

Monday, January 5, 2009

Sweetness

We live ever at the whim of our muses and my schAUdenfreude1 demands this: the Sugar Bowl was the best game all year that I didn't get to see. Thank God it's on hulu. I may yet go view the game2... or I may not. My angry blood demands I revel in their losses, but it loses the forest for the trees - every yard forward a crime. Like a good horror movie, it's hard not to wince even when you know the good guys will make it out3, somehow.

And in a season of bizarrity and bafflement, it was damn near the perfect icing on the hat.

Like Jerry, I don't buy the Andre-Smith-ruined-Bammar-durr argument. Andre Smith didn't play on defense. And while his absence was worth more than a few of those eight glorious sacks, and even given that there is undoubtedly bleedthrough from the offense's morale to the defense's, I don't buy the idea that a well-coached defense will implode when the offense struggles. Nick Saban's built a strong, well-coached defense. A strong, well-coached defense that got snockered by some angry Utes. Not only did they not show up, they never really made it into the stadium.

Did you see the Rose Bowl? Did you, like I, witness the irreverent stomping of Paterno's proud lions? The first half was pure misery, an embarrassment. Penn State's beleaguered cornerbacks were breaking their own ankles on the turf of Rose Bowl Stadium and Sanchez was hurling the ball all over them, hammering the seams in the cover 3 with impunity. But things changed. "Now is when USC always puts the hammer down," the bantermongers drooled. They mocked JoePa's simple halftime advice: go play Penn State football. This, we were told, was the sign of a doddering old fogey, a shell of a coach who tottered down from the press box to peddle his mealy-mouthed sentimentality. A man long past the proper arc. Once again, the bantermongers got it all wrong.

Don't get me wrong - I don't mean to claim that significant adjustments were made by the coaching staff. They were. But Penn State started playing the game. And made the second half a real contest. So yeah, scoreboard and all that, but Penn State playing Penn State football was the clear victor of the second half. Had they played the entire game with that gusto, we'd have seen a different outcome in Pasadena.

Seems that Bama wasn't able to make the same sort of mental, emotional, and physical adjustments. Arenas being given credit for blowing the special teams wide open, the Crimson Tide couldn't even fight the Utes to less than a draw after a disastrous first quarter. By report, the Utes dominated their opponent in every phase of the game. So while Penn State got their fangs out and fought back hard against a more highly-regarded opponent simply by playing Penn State football, Bama couldn't dig out of their hole - hell, couldn't even dig.

Where was Bama football then?

Where was their vaunted tradition, the legacy, the swagger of the storied past? Perhaps, like their mammoth left tackle and Saban's pride in his lip-bustin' line of red elephants - like those less-than-worthy scholarship players in the year of their oversigning - like those 115 years of vicious, hatchet-exhuming, face-spiting hatred for our beloved tigers...

...perhaps it was merely relinquished. And the soul of the squad gone with it.




1 schAUdenfreude(n): glee taken by Auburn fans in the failures of Alabama in any and all realm of life, which to an outside observer may find unsettling. Frequently it commands me and I embarrass myself.

2 My darling fiancee has call later this week. Maybe then, if I can bear to see them make a first down.

3 Actually, the demons don't always get what's for. The 2008 Iron Bowl ended something like this.

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Solstice

First of all you've got to understand, it's a bleak picture I have in my Auburn brain.


Like some other Auburn bloggers, Tuberville IS (WAS) Auburn to me. I was 15 when he took over from Terry Bowden, and living in the football hell that is central Virginia. He's all I know practically of football at all, and the Tommy I knew was a rock in the tempest, a JetGate-defying long-hauler, a man whose cachet was the surprise onside kick and the out-of-the-blue reverse pass. Tommy Tuberville represented rock-solid stability in the face of any challenge. And in the final year of his tenure on the Plains, that coolness under fire disappeared. The CEO mismanaged his players, his assistants, and especially his most important coordinator. And was fired. My world's been shook. Auburn football is wrong side out this winter.

What's more, Chizik fit the bleak, bleak bill for the every-other Tiger coach, a pro-and-con five-year program reboot. At best, I felt that very good excuses could be made for his current record as a head coach, that we could confidently move his indicator from the bright-red realm of "FAIL" to the middling yellow uncertainty just below the center of the dial. IE, perhaps it's not fair to judge a first-time head coach on a scant two seasons at one of college footballs perennial dirt-munchers1. But what was undoubtedly certain was that Gene Chizik had done nothing to prove himself worthy of the job. At least not in a public sense. God knows what the Jays unearthed in the man, or remembered in him, that swayed their decision from his battle-hardened competition. I sure didn't know. He was - and to a large extent, remains - a definite maybe. Would he be Barfield or Bowden?

And so, imagine my surprise when he toed the party line of relentless Dye-inspired mouthsmashin'. After all, what were the fans, the linemen, and the running backs clamoring for? More three-pointin', tooth-rattlin' foobaw, more clouds of dust and grass-plastered helmets. Everyone was ready for ta bust 'em in the mouth. Chizik knew what he had to say.

Even I was ready! Let it be said - if it even need be - that I'm a huge fan of the spread philosophy, and in fact think that the Auburn Tiger offense has put on a "why you need the spread" clinic for the past two years. I was Frankly delirious after the Clemson game. I was eager for more of the Tony Franklin Experience, and ready to inhale deeply. And I loved to see our spread in action! There is little-to-no doubt in my mind that if Kodi Burns had played meaningful snaps in 2007, he would have been the clear starter in 2008. And there is even less doubt in my mind that an experienced Kodi Burns would have made the difference in Death Valley2. But after the LSU game, the game when the Spread Eagle starting darting around the field, hampered though she was - when even that game our passing game almost won, when even the best drive of that game had my father bellowing "Bring back Pat Dye! Bring back Pat Dye! Bring back Pat Dye!" ... I didn't think we were ready here at Auburn. The fans aren't the team by any stretch, and all in all what damns we give don't matter, but Lord Almighty... the monolith was trembling. The center could not hold. And of course, shortly after another heartrending Hat-tastic "almost" in the Bayou, the center gave way. Everything fell apart. We spit out the fireplug and kept in our mouth the lukewarm, offensively stagnant bunch of dudes who were "already out of football." We weren't ready. I had consigned myself to the shield of orthodoxy, and braced for five years of grind-like-a-millstone Big Blue groundpounding. Mississippi State with a pulse and old-school badassitude even in the face of certain box-stacking.

War Damn Eagle anyway, and all that. Like I said, the picture was bleak. And then: Malzahn. Gus Malzahn...

My first reaction was to resume panic. As in, OH GOD WHY ARE WE DOING THIS AGAIN OH GOD. The last thing Auburn needs is more self-inflicted mayhem. Regardless of Chizik's encouraging ability to identify a high-profile guy and go git 'im, it seemed that another spread jockey was to be wrangled awkwardly into place only to have his hopes and dreams splattered as his predecessor's. When I suggested "Winesburg, Alabama" as a name for the 2008 season, I meant it. Bleak.

But as Chizik and Malzahn began to address their public, this initial hysteria quieted. Everyone by now has heard how Chizik is going to let Malzahn have a say in the structure of the offense and the hiring of assistants, and is rightly pleased. But - courtesy of Jay G. Tate - this is what Malzahn had to say:
That's what I did today -- spent time evaluating our strengths.

Well, you got to be balanced, and you've got to take what the defense gives you. People tell me, hey, do you want to run more than throw? Really, it matters on what the defense is going to give you.

We're going throw the ball far downfield, and we're going to do that quite often.

[When I talk to the players,] we will definitely put up exactly who we are, we will put up our goals... we'll have a good sound plan, and we'll have extremely high goals.
Now, some may dismiss that as coachspeak, pandering, or well-duh-isms. But our current situation dictates what the "Well duh" will be. And this year, what is "well duh" is play to our strengths, balance in the context of the opposing defensive scheme, and stretch the field. None of which was done consistently in 2008. Taken with Chizik's generous proclamations, this is the message I heard:
We have identified the lethal mistakes that were made and publicly announce our desire to correct them.
Hallelujah. This is the real ray of light, the sign that the dawn marches ever earlier after our dark solstice.


So with my worst fears placated for the moment, I gradually started to recall our own brief experiences with the man who first populated my nightmares with fleet-footed midgets:


It's like a horror movie, like, Guys! Guys! Look out! Guys he's RIGHT THERE LOOK OUT GUYS OH NOOOOOO!



Malzahn who, I'm certain, has never been witnessed in the same room with another weirdly insightful man among the nerdier of my heroes:


Good Offense! du-du-du-Du-du-du-du-Du!

So, Auburn Tigers. There may be reason to hope, after all. Chizik may not be the second coming of Doug. Malzahn may get to trick out the offense with his warp-speed wizardry. And we may yet see Auburn be Auburn again.

The dawn marches ever earlier.


1 Just to momentarily address that lurking double standard: Turner Gill went 7 and 17 at Buffalo in his first two seasons at then-ultradoormat Buffalo. So there, Round Mound. Eat you damn shoe.

2 And we'd still have a rough-hewn Tony Franklin, Tommy Tuberville's fading panache, and all those grumbling hangers-on of assistant coaches who didn't really want to be coaching, after all. The Lord works in mysterious ways... toward mysterious ends.

Sunday, December 14, 2008

Chizik

Oh brother.


Maybe Not as Bad as He Appears
we are ever the contrarian

Yes, Chizik has been phenomenally awful at Iowa State. Yes, it would be much more encouraging if Auburn had hired a coach with a proven track record of winning. But this football program has a history of discovering and developing talent. For instance, this guy:

Gorgeous!


We think fondly on Borges' tenure on the Plains, and remember him as a genius hire by a shrewd Tuberville - who was ever able to find the diamond in the rough. What we don't remember is just how rough the rough was. In 2001, Borges coached the California offense to the lofty pinnacle of... a 1-10 record, outscored 201-431, and hanging 20 points on a Scarlet Knight squad that gave up 38 points per game in nine losses to teams neither Navy nor Buffalo. After being fired en masse with the rest of the Golden Bear coaches, he joined the staff of Indiana in 2002 and was annihilated, outscored overall 258-445, three wins over William & Mary, Wisconsin, and Central Michigan. 2003? His offense scored 177 points in 11 games, breaking the 17-point barrier in just two contests - a win against Indiana State and a loss to Northwestern.

And then he led the Tiger O to an undefeated SEC season, coached Jason Campbell out of a yawning pit of Nall-inflicted despair and into the first round, and was named the 2005 Rivals Offensive coach of the year.

So with Al looking over our shoulders, I'd give Chizik the benefit of the doubt. It's clear that Jacobs and crew didn't hire based on track record, but based on something else - maybe the kind of intuition that led us to hire Borges in a similarly chaotic offseason? I remember Chizik fondly as well, and it's clear from his stints at Auburn and Texas that he knows how to coach.

Moreover, in looking at the mighty Cyclones' consistent history of beaks in the dirt, I could be convinced that Chizik could not have run them into the ground because the ground is where the Cyclones feel most comfortable. It's homey, familiar - per Wikipedia, Chizik's predecessor McCarney "was fired after going 4-8 in his final season, despite 5 bowl appearances during his tenure, the most of any Iowa State coach." McCarney coached for twelve years at Iowa State and garnered a school-record 5 bowl games. Iowa State - to be blunt - is a football team that is trying to look upward from its faceful of mud and sees nothin' but catfish bellies. Coaching such a perennial turf-eater into even modest success may have been more than a mouthful for a guy who'd been a non-position coach at a major program for five seasons.

Just sayin'. I'm trying really, really hard to find the reasons why our hire of a 5-191 coach isn't a complete and total misjudge of ability.


But Here's the Rub

There's more than mere X's/O's talent to being Auburn's head coach. Just look at Tuberville, Iron Bowl dominator, BCS martyr and talent discoverer extraordinaire. All the coaching capital he had accumulated proved illiquid in the context of a bad losing season. And out he went, regardless of a coach-slaying, Jetgate-defying tenure of legend.

What's that you say? Jetgate? Tuberville used to be able to stand up to the kinds of pressures that he faced this season. Hearken back to the winter after 2003, when Jetgate: exposed gave him a single year to save his neck. He dug up Al. 2008 was a completely different story. By my estimation, Tubby lost his head coach position not because he was no longer a good coach (I think he still was) but because he wasn't playing his own CEO game anymore. He mismanaged coaches, mismanaged players, and then got ousted by Jacobs in bizarre circumstances. How do you miss or fail to correct for a problem of this magnitude:
While waiting for his final flight as an Auburn employee, Nall talks with long-time friend Henry Griffin. He owns Southern AG Carriers. That's where Nall works these days. "He asked me: `Are you ready to get out of coaching?' I was already out of it.2
The bottom line is that he couldn't play the people game anymore and died a political death as the consequence. Coming from 5-19 squalor at Iowa State, does Chizik has any capital whatsoever with which to play the game as Auburn plays it?


Here's Our Quandary, Auburn Tigers

Who has both the coaching capital and the willingness to invest?

The proven coaches (Leach) and the upwardly mobile (Gill?) don't want any part of lethal problems that they can't fix (Jacobs.) The only guys we can get are the guys that need the gig and would be willing to live their life under the axe. Guys who have talent, but have struggled when given the reins of ramshackle football teams. Guys who weren't as ready to renovate that vine-covered vacant house as they thought, but will settle for moving in with their nasty ol' mother-in-law and doing some home improvements.

(Chizik.)





1 Speaking medically: baaaaaaaaarrrff
2 courtesy of the HABOTN

Sunday, December 7, 2008

Is this... is this somehow... better?

Let it be know that I will entertain no scenario in which losing to Bama is considered to be "good" thing. And by "good" I even mean, "just this side of morally reprehensible." But with Florida beating Bama in the SECCG, there's a hell of a silver lining. Bear with me.

Exhibit A: Don't get me wrong: I'm not clever enough to cry sour grapes about the Iron Bowl - dammit I love me some grapes. I want grapes so bad. But it was pretty unlikely that Auburn would triumph in this past Iron Bowl. Yes it hurts. Yes, it's devastating. But no, it was not unlikely. It became clear after the Arkansas game that a victory over the Tide was not a reasonable goal in 2008. So we were, in some way, ready for it.

Exhibit B: the rise of the new "Auburn who?" Bammer. Auburn who? The team who beat us six years straight and now we don't care anymore Auburn? The cross-state college we don't hate anymore Auburn? Second-consideration to Tennessee, SECCG, and number 13 Auburn?

Miami here we come! All we've got to do is...


Oh. Well %@$&.

Tiger fans: they ain't got a leg to stand on! Having cast aside our traditional rivalry under the auspices of a fully transcendent, Sabanized squad, they've got no hate to fall back on should they lose. And lose they did. Bama don't even get to sniff at the national championship.


Warning: approaching critical schadenfreude levels.



Crimson cake, neither to be eaten nor to be had! Bitches.


So take heart, plainsmen and plainswomen. It's sure depressing to lose an Iron Bowl - I'd forgotten how depressing - but we were well-shored-up for that hurricane of schaden. We can now add the -freude on the end, seeing that that Bama's knocked themselves out of consideration for the one thing they claim to desire and can't even lord it over us1.


War Damn Eagle Forever.




1 Not without a torrent of hypocrisy, that is, and we all know it's coming. Just goes to show we're better than them.

Friday, December 5, 2008

Oh Cap'n Me Cap'n


I was a bit let down to see that Cap'n Leach wouldn't be coming to the Plains, but not really surprised.

For one, the patterns wouldn't have fit. If you look at the history of Auburn football coaches post-WWII, a very clear pattern emerges. Auburn alternates between short-term benchwarmers and long-term coaches that we frankly run into the ground. When the Honda Accord finally coughs up its transmission, we scrap it for a Pontiac Sunfire with a sunroof. And soon after, when the seats have mildewed and the fun has worn out of that five-speed, Auburn finds another Honda Accord. Ten years later, repeat. Why that is, I can only speculate. Perhaps, when our long-tenured coaches leave, too much of their shadow lingers, too much of the culture they created remains. And so, we have to reset the program. Or, since they are so entrenched after ten years of administration, the necessary and difficult adjustments can not be made. And the program isn't ready for its next big man to settle in. Maybe, for whatever bizarrely poor luck plaguing us, we always seem to lose our head coach in a down year for hirees (as would seem to be the case this winter.) Whatever the cause, we're about ripe for another Terry Bowden, not another Pat Dye, historically speaking.

Moreso, I never really believed Leach was terribly interested in Auburn. In fact, not one of the prominent rumors has seemed even remotely credible to me so far, with Leach's name being bandied about with Nutt, Petrino, and Johnson. All of the latter three are first-year, just-unpacked coaches. Petrino is a soulless mercenary who nearly stole Tubby's job, so it would be a bit two-faced to give Tubby 5.1 million dollars out of the goodness of our hearts and then poke him right in the eye. Houston Nutt is the anti-Les Miles, just as crazy but can't catch a break - oh, and that would extend our streak of poaching Ole Miss's coaches to two. And Paul Johnson has been extremely successful at Georgia Tech right out of the gate, lives in Atlanta, and would have to be bought at a high price.

But Leach especially. In Texas Tech, his squads are successful in an extremely competitive division and it's largely because he's given the latitude to run his team absolutely as he pleases. Auburn's a bad fit for two reasons: its athletic department's meddlesome ways and its hesitance to embrace the next revolution in offensive football. The first, I'm afraid, don't seem to be changing anytime soon. The latter will take some time, but it's adequately clear that the program - the culture of the program - isn't there. Don't get me wrong - I think we've all learned our lesson about slapdashing a brand-new exotic offense into place with neither the players, the necessary staff, nor the mere willingness to do it right. But we've long hunkered behind the shield of orthodoxy, content to bash our way downfield, helmet-to-helmet with the fast, lanky blockers on the perimeter occasionally surprising the defense by sneakily catching passes. I don't think we're ready to air it out Pirate-Style.

The caveat, of course, is that much of my formative years of Auburn football fandom have come during the Tuberville decade. I'm used to his model of meh wide receivers, offense-is-just-another-kind-of-special-teams, and soul-wringing defense. It's quite possible that with Tubby and his crew1 packing up shop, this vision of football could similarly fade. But even Al Borges' take on the West Coast was practically high-tech when he arrived at Auburn. I can only think of my dad screaming "Bring back Pat Dye! Bring back Pat Dye!" via cellphone during the LSU game, the only game in which a yolk-bedraggled Spread Eagle chipped away with her egg tooth. I don't even need to point out that any spread guru attempting to peddle his razzle-dazzlery will meet with serious resistance.

Resistance that Leach does not need to endure in Lubbock. There, he's got carte blanche to wing the pigskin all over the field and line up touchdowns like birds on a wire. In Auburn, he'd be selling his system all over again, the minute that nameplate went up on Tuberville's old door. Even for a whippersnappin' 47-year-old eccentric, that's a tall order. Whatever raise Auburn could give him, is it enough to pay for the grief he'll get?

So I don't think he had any intention of being one a' th' lovely landlubbers.


The other thing to consider is that we may be in for some dark times. The specter of Doug Barfield and his veer offense is looming darkly, moreso than in decades. Remember of course that the veer's ("wishbone minus fullback") modern expression is in the run-first spread. Are there any available coaches who can make the run-first spread hum and would be willing to try foisting it on the Tigers? How ironic would it be2 if we picked slimly among the run-first spread minds - in a year already being heralded as the spread's peak by some - and ended up with a second iteration of mis-managed option running?

Color me despondent, Auburn, in these neck-torquing weeks of wild speculation. It's a little much to take. But I'd almost rather we settle for now, and not re-Barfield our program.


1 God help me if any of those jokers are retained. God help me. I will start a freakin' riot.
2 Note the post tag - these may be the most delectable words I'll ever taste and War Eagle. Like broccoli cooked in brown gravy.

Monday, December 1, 2008

I stand corrected

In an earlier post, I posted a video of Bo Over the Top and remarked that I, as nascent humanity, was enwombed somewhere to the left of the YouTube screen. Here it is again:

Glory!


Well, I was wrong. Says my Dad:
In that clip, you're on the opposite end of the field, on the opposite side of the field from the camera. We had to look for the referees' signal(s) on that play.

Our tickets were (section/row/seat) 41-43-21 and 42-48-13 (we had to get tickets however we could... Mom had to "sneak in" as a student). We didn't sit in those seats though...

These tickets:



He continues:
From seating charts available online, we were in section 40, just on the "field side" of the south end zone - I couldn't quite see straight down the end zone line - and we were pretty close to the right end of the row. We weren't under the upper deck.

So the 3rd jpeg shows about where we were.



GLORY... and RIGHTEOUSNESS... Amen, and amen.


Amen!

Sunday, November 30, 2008

post-game

Every tiger fan who lamented the "non-competitiveness" of the Iron Bowl had their wish granted: welcome back to the past, tigers. This is easily the worst defeat I have ever seen my tigers suffer at the hands of the Crimson Tide. The historical frame I put it in: 36-0 in 2008 looks very much like 35-0 in 1973. Maybe I'll think more about this game later.

But for now, it's Sunday. Go to church. God will forgive us.


War Eagle, Forever.

Thursday, November 27, 2008

Digging up the Hatchet, 2008

So real life has conspired to keep me off the blog lately. Don't look at me like that. I've been to Winston-Salem, Johnson City TN, Nashville, Cleveland, Raleigh-Durham, Pittsburgh, Hershey, Huntington WV, New York, Richmond, Rochester, New York, Columbus Ohio, and Greensboro in the past three weeks. In that order.

But it's the week leading up to the Iron Bowl. I am compelled to write something.

Pre-game analysis is at this point moot, and more effectively pursued by those who've been able to watch the recent games. The bottom line as far as I can see is that we got pissed off against Ole Miss, we showed that we could have beaten Georgia with a few breaks, and we’ve had a solid two weeks to get rared up for the Iron Bowl - I'm encouraged. Beyond that, I’m not going to X ‘n O it, as the X’s and O’s are neither clear nor encouraging, and I’m not going to be the one to sift through our season of DEATH to find the glimmers of hope still holding their breath in the wreckage and therefore jinx the Story indelibly on the intertubes. If anyone’s disappointed, well, they can get their bellyful of freudeschaden by reading my truly glorious preview of the LSU game.

But that’s neither here nor there. It’s HATE week.

It'll rust if you just leave it there, underground.


So what's more interesting to me is the recent paradigm shift in the state of Bama fandom.

Maybe I'm just old-school - fortunate to be thoroughly brewed in our bitter Alabaman past - but I hate Bama. My father will have the blame and credit for that, for he is an Auburn fan to end all Auburn fans, a man who traces his blue-and-orange blood back to our pre-civil war ancestors. The neighbors, peacefully walking their dogs on Saturdays in autumn, are no longer startled when they hear him bellowing inside our house from the other side of the street. He grew up in Montgomery, and his allegiance was forged in that most crushing of decades, the long haul from 1972 and "Punt Bama Punt" to Bo Over the Top in 1982. As a child, he watched most of that 1972 game on television. Late in the game, Bama was cramming the football down our throat and he was literally driven from his home by the flood of calls from his Bammer classmates. He lived through the near-decade of agony that followed. He became a student at Auburn himself, and met my mother there. And in 1982, when Bo went over the Alabama line straight into the heart of the Crimson Tide, taking with him the famous words on which the Bear would ever gnaw... my father was there. My mother was there. And I was there, in the womb, as he and she and thousands upon thousands of Auburn faithful erupted. Victory! My mother was knocked down a row or two when he sprang to his feet - War Damn Eagle!


Press play. I am somewhere to the left of your screen.
Eleven seconds in, my world gets permanently shook.


Explains a lot, one could say. As should be obvious by now, I’ve been toted about in blue and orange since the day I first entered God’s green earth at Lee County Hospital. And almost as long as that, I’ve been well-instructed in the hate. Not just any old hate. The kind of hate that Hamilcar Barca administered unto his son Hannibal with the strength of an oath. A hate that has little equal. Ohio State and Michigan fans, for instance, will quickly point out that they, too, hate each other, and if you pal around in Ann Arbor wearing silver and scarlet or stroll into a Buckeye bar in Columbus humming “Hail to the Victors,” you’re itchin’ for a beatdown. Maybe that’s true. But hate ain’t about beer-addled twenty-somethings dustin’ up over “disrespect” and such like. Hate’s better than a mere rivalry. And maybe I’ll be the first to say it, but in that respect the Iron Bowl isn't a rivalry game because it isn't really a rivalry at all. Rivalries are born on the gridiron and spill out into the rest of the year by virtue of their implications. Ohio State - Michigan is a great rivalry. They’re two storied teams that have clashed over and over, often with national ambitions hanging in the balance. Bowl games, championships, trophies - ever do the Buckeyes and Wolverines stand in each other’s path, and from this mutual blockade flows the hostility. But had the Wolverines and Buckeyes never played, they wouldn’t have a hate at all. That's a rivalry.

Had Auburn and Alabama never played, it would only have been worse. What lives between Auburn and Alabama is itself sovereign, and not the child of mere football. It grew up all on its own, gnarling deep in four and a half million hearts, 364 days of the year, waiting to emerge from its lair and hurl young blood headlong into young blood for a savage four hours. Our hate, having festered in the wilderness for an entire year, enters into the stadium like a demon summoned to an altar, ready for the bloodletting. It demands the contest, not (as in mere rivalry) the other way around. The university presidents of the two schools knew it and wanted no part of the madness, when so long ago they refused to pit their young men against each other to slake the thirst of the Yellowhammer State. It would be a gruesome tilt to overshadow any other, they protested, driving the weak-spirited before it in horror. Oh how right they were about that. How deeply true it is that to become a citizen of Alabama is to become enter one of two fiefdoms, to be owned wholesale. Those young men belonged to the malice - it demanded their youth. And oh how bad we wanted it anyway.

Scratch that - it's hard to say "want it" when I don't even like the Iron Bowl. It's hard to enjoy the game when the moral, even synderetic significance of the game is palpable - every yard given up to the Tide an affront to human decency, every first down is a sheer crime, and may God forgive us if we're beaten. It isn't fun, it's work. I grind my teeth a little flatter every year even when we win. Moreover it has little to do with our standing in the conference or the nation. In fact, I most enjoy the years when neither team stands to make national gains from our regional grind. With nothing to distract from the grisly task, our moral certitude is even clearer. Put it to you this way: looking forward to the Iron Bowl as a springboard to national aspirations is as foreign to me as going to church with the hopes of getting all the money out of the offering plates. You go to that game to give, not to take. To sacrifice for the greater good. So I'm not one of the Auburn fans who claimed boredom with an Iron Bowl devoid of "implications." I don't care if it's competitive - all I want is their hearts broken. I want old ladies going up to Nick Saban and asking "When are we going to beat those people?" We could beat Bama by nine touchdowns for fifty years and it wouldn't be enough. Had they gotten the "death penalty" as they richly deserved, had they become financially destitute and utterly talentless, I would still grit my teeth for every play and I would still exult in every victory, every single year. It's the oath I inherited, the roar of Jordan-Hare still echoing through amnion and umbilicus, twenty-six years later.

And while many Auburn fans don’t drink as deeply from that goblet of teeth-gnashing fandom, we're united in that unalloyed devotion to the school. It's true - as is so smugly pointed out - that Auburn never was a beauty queen and probably never will be. Our fans are quick to point out 2004's disaster, and it will ever rankle, but nearly as galling was 1983, the year of my birth and the bowl season after Bo over the top. We were leap-frogged by the newcomer Miami because they were new on the scene, and we were stonewalled by Oklahoma because they had always been around. Whatev. As an Auburn fan, I've been trained my entire life not to be an attention whore troubled by the uninformed opinions of sportwriters and haggard coaches. I have no illusions about the polls, about "history," about being the hotshot - the only meritocracy in college football is sixty minutes between the sidelines. When we win out, we go to the SECCG or we go to a great bowl. While it's frustrating sometimes for our team to be overlooked, there's a kind of pyrrhic honor therein. By my estimation, everything Auburn gets Auburn has earned. And that includes our fans. Auburn fans root for Auburn - not for the polls, not for the BCS, not for a history that they may never have lived. Big Blue. And I'm proud to be a part of that. The commercials are cheesy but true: we're a family and we recognize one another.

Bama is entirely different, ever the pageant contestant consumed by the gaze of the masses. And it seems it's not the point why or from where the attention comes - the culture that surrounds the University of Alabama seems to be "any focus on us is good." Which cuts two ways.

The first is the wide legion of Bamagroupies (groupiebammers? ironically, grammers?) that crawl out from under every rock whenever Bama is "back." Which, somehow, Bama manages to be "back" every other year. My father (totally unbiased, mind you) will rail on about all the Bama fans who've never even been south of Tennessee or east of Mississippi and couldn't find T-town on a map of Tuscaloosa county. I wouldn't begrudge the Tide their success on the field, moral affrontery though it may be. But the flood of OMIGAWD BAMARR YAWL that festoons the intertubes every time SJPW completes a pass is damn near comical. But also, meaningless. For instance, you may also have been audience to the joker who left a blithely anonymous comment over on a JCCW post:
So let me get this straight, after all thats happened this year, if Auburn manages to knock off Bama, Auburn fans will happy about this season? Dear God that is pathetic...
At first I thought to myself, oh hell, another fool Bammer crying sour grapes. After all, how can this guy not understand what kind of satisfaction that would bring? I figured that their spirit was simply broken, crushed under the weight of six straight defeats, of three senior classes that would never beat the Auburn Tigers. That they were unable to bring themselves to express any hope for fear of mentally reliving the past six years. But it gradually dawned on me: this guy has absolutely no clue what team he's rooting for. Else he wouldn't need “his” own team's history spelled out for him. When an alleged Bama fan tells me he don't hate Auburn or claims not to understand our dream of spoiling the Tide's season, I just think he's not a Bama fan. He's merely another hanger-on with no connection to the actual university. That, or a rabble-rouser who thinks himself sly and aloof as he anonymously rouses the rabble on the intertubes in a manner that divorces his image from his fanhood. Either way: throwaway, and familiar practice from the grammers. I'm glad not to have to deal with that kind of fan.

The second way is of the last-words-of-a-redneck variety. Par example, Jerry at the JCCW pointed out the bammer-tastic smack talkin' over at West By God Virginia, back before the Mountaineer game. Any Auburn fan whose spleen needs a pre-Iron Bowl ticklin' should get on over there and bask in the anti-glory. It's a feast for the eye and the conscience:
Auburn [is still] destined to live in the shadow of the Crimson Tide no matter what their successes or our failures.

Consider: Since 1996, the year Gene Stallings stepped down as the head coach of the Crimson Tide, Alabama has seen more turmoil in just over a decade than many programs have seen throughout the course of their entire existance[sic]. Five different coaches have been hired in that time span, with two of them being derailed by sordid sex scandals (one of whom never even coached a down because of it), one of them abandoning the program due to impending NCAA probation, and one landing the job by virtue of having played quarterback for the school in the 80s and not much more. The program was run into the ground and embarassed by all means imaginable, while Auburn rose to the ranks of the SEC “elite” during that time, and yet all of the focus remained on Alabama.
News flash: gettin' all the 'tention cause you're acting like a bunch of degenerate hillbillies is really, really bad. So immature - would the average Tiger fan talk so blithely of a complete failure of character that plagued our school for a rip-roarin' decade? Not that we would do such a thing, or even if we did, not that we as fans would be caught dead taking pride therein. No, Alabama, that shadow you cast as you shamble out of the strip joint is not one that falls on Auburn.

Neither is this behavior new.

But what's most intriguing about the smack-talking post, though, is not the sleight-of-hand that allows him to claim that no one cares about Auburn because they couldn't tear their eyes away from the Crimson Tide's humiliating train wreck of a decade1. Nor is it the nifty trick whereby he claims to be above hating Auburn, and yet still revels in Bama gettin' all the 'tention, y'all. What's most interesting is the simultaneous embracing and rejection of Tide history that distinguishes the new Bama fan. On one hand, he's obviously denying more than a century of vicious, gladiatorial combat in the form of football. As I need not mention, this is a war fought long by our fathers and grandfathers - and in my case, great-great-grandfathers. To claim that the Iron Bowl holds no significance is to completely ignore the bitter feud that has shaped our two institutions. All while simultaneously proclaiming the resurrection of the Tide, return to the glories of the Alabama past, the days of a new Bear - this itself is an appeal to history, to trudishun, to legacy. Mmm, crimson cake to be eaten and to be had!


Can't have your Bear and eat him, too.... er....


And yet these two aspects of Alabama's history are inextricably intertwined. For one, they are united in the Bear. Just go back to his famous2 proclamations before and after the 1972 Iron Bowl - that he would rather lose to Texas ten times than to Auburn once, and that he would never lose to Auburn ever again. The titan of Tide history knew that Texas was a rival and Auburn an enemy. To appeal to the national significance Bama attained under Paul Bryant and yet discount wholesale the passion he had for the game seems distinctly un-Bammerly - downright heretical, even.

But even Bryant's recognition of the Iron Bowl's significance is mere symptom and should be taken as such, lest we repeat the mistakes of our universities' past presidents. Each university in turn feared that a gridiron manifestation of the hate would overtake the entire state's culture, but in truth it is the state's culture. Like I said before, rivalries are born in tough games in which hearts are broken and dreams are made, but in our war - our hate - football is merely the expression of a symbiotic hostility that lives all on its own. This is no casual diversion to be brushed aside when inconvenient, it's life in Alabama. Hell, it's life in upstate New York. I remember my 10th grade earth science teacher, a hard-bitten New Englander who got on my case for saying "Yes ma'am" because she thought I was smarting off. "Oh I know Auburn alright," she said one day, having seen me in my Auburn cap. She told me the story of two kids she taught back in upstate, a boy and a girl who became friends, grew in affection, and began dating. However, it was soon discovered that one family was from Auburn, and the other from Alabama. In a rare display of mutual intention, both sets of parents put an end to the relationship. Immediately. This is, as my dad puts it, a hate that ends marriages and bankrupts businesses. And by God, those businesses should fail. If their owners haven't the acumen to understand the state in which they live, they ought not set up shop within the Yellowhammer's borders.



As you can see, to deny our enmity is to deny our very statehood, and the history that flows from it. Again, it must be said that many uneducated groupies can do so without real intellectual consequence - these remoras can't be faulted for not knowing whence the whale has swum. But I'm convinced that a growing number of genuine Bammers are going down that path. When a Bammer says on one hand that Bama is better because the nation gawked at theirs, the most dramatic and most public self-humiliation endured by an academic football squad, and on the other hand tries to claim they have outgrown the sordid, snarling grudge between our schools that is such a facet of Alabaman life... well, what can a plainsman or plainswoman do but shake their head? Isn't it clear that you can't logically claim to have transcended the boundaries of Alabama and still claim the expression of its skankiest, most stereoptypical qualities as your nimbus? Would the Tide truly have us believe that they have somehow become greater than the petty infighting of the state of Alabama, as evidenced by their decade of redneck revelry and near-execution? How embarassing.

Yes, Alabama, the world will show up to take in the spectacle, but at the end of the day.... that's all it is.


So take heart, tigers. We may be beaten on the field, but we should take pride on this Thanksgiving that we will never be those people.


War. Damn. Eagle. Kick 'em in the teeth Big Blue.





1 Though it is clever, I'll have to admit.
2 And famously edible.

Monday, November 3, 2008

War Damn Eagle

Didn't see the Ole Miss game. Didn't really have to. From reading the numbers, I can clearly picture what transpired.


Welcome to Waffle House! How would you like your 2008 Auburn Tigers?
I'll have mine, spread, Hatted, Johnsoned, Petrinoed, Stewarted and Nutted... but not Croomed.


Going Through the Progression
as bright spots go, this is clearly a checkdown

I was happy to see that wacky pass-run ratio for two reasons. The first is that Kodi is still an excitable little fella, and he needs as much throwing time as possible to take the green out of the greenhorn. The second is that Ensminger showed he'll attempt to adjust to the weakness of opposing defenses. Ole Miss's back four were there to be thrown on, and throw we did. Maybe the plan still failed miserably, but hey, at least we correctly identified the soft spot and we sold out trying to stab at it.

We'll take what we can get. Sort of we will.


Better men than me

By any estimation, you initially arrived at this blog via the Joe Cribbs Car Wash or some other such outstanding blog written by an actual sportswriter. So perhaps it's unnecessary to link these things - but credit where it's due. Here are a couple of intriguing factoids:

Our defensive injury report, courtesy of Jay G. Tate:
DT Sen'Derrick Marks: ankle (day to day)
DT Tez Doolittle: groin (day to day)
DE Michael Goggans: ankle (day to day)
DE Antonio Coleman: both ankles (day to day)
DT Mike Blanc: left hand (to be determined)
SLB Craig Stevens: left hamstring, turf toe (playing through it)
MLB Tray Blackmon: broken right wrist (out for season)
MLB Josh Bynes: "deep thigh bruise" (day to day)
WLB Merrill Johnson: hamstring (day to day)
CB Aairon Savage: right knee (out for season)
CB Walt McFadden: left knee and ankle (day to day)
CB Jerraud Powers: hamstring (out for at least one more week)
CB Neiko Thorpe: ankle (out for at least one more week)
On most every other defense in the country, this is would be a starting lineup.


Over at From the Bleachers, we're reminded of this startling fact:
It's also clear that every defense the Tigers play knows exactly what Auburn is going to do before they do it, especially in the running game. AU can't run inside, can't run to the outside, and can't even run a screen without having three defenders around the ball at all times. This is not a surprise, or at least it shouldn't be. The last time Steve Ensminger was in charge of the offense, the same thing happened; Georgia Tech's defenders in 2003 were calling out the plays from the line of scrimmage. I wouldn't be surprised if Ole Miss was doing the same thing over five years later.
Ouch. Just... ouch. The mysterious1 ascendency of Kodi Burns to the throne of starterdom aside, there are some times when I wish we still had a certain offensive coordinator. Or, to be fair, an offensive coordinator. At all.

Also from that FTB article,
Saturday was easily Burns' most productive game as a Tiger, but those three awful interceptions doomed any chance of getting a win. But then again, Burns is now being "coached" by a guy who took an eventual first-round NFL starter and wrecked him so badly that people wondered whether the guy would ever play again.
Burns will do fine once he has a coach again.


Track 'Em Tigers has an unusually apt name for their latest article:
Auburn Braces For Tough Stretch Run
Apt because this is a stretch run2:
You may recognize this play by its east-by-northeast trajectory as the stretch run that Ben Tate and Co. have been bracing for, all season long.




1 Ok, yeah, not really that mysterious.
2 Courtesy of the NCAA 2009 pdf of Texas Tech's playbook, ace H pro set.